I have several (5 - 6) friends who see everything (and generally have the same taste) and none liked it…several hated it. I have not liked the music that I have heard. From my reading of many reviews, it’s premise just doesn’t appeal to me.
Re ignoring my reservations and seeing it anyway, as an out-of-towner (Florida and Massachusetts), I generally only get to see 12 - 15 shows on Broadway a season…it just doesn’t make the cut. Every year, there are shows I don’t get to see that I want to; why use a limited slot for something that doesn’t sound appealing? Note: this season, I was unable to see The Minutes and Take Me Out, both of which I wanted to see. I figured that I had seen the original production of TMO and really liked it, so that decision was relatively easy; I rationalized that The Minutes will probably appear in one of the regional theatre companies at some time. I was also unable to squeeze in Girl from North Country. I was able to see in my last visit: How I Learned to Drive, POTUS, Harry Potter (my wife wanted to see it more than me), Hangmen, Phantom (only Monday night at 8:00pm option), Tina (again, my wife’s choice), SIX, and a performance at ABT, so It was a pretty good week.