What a thread you Cabaret Folk have here! Wow! I was reading all your posts and wanted to put my 2 bits in here. I have seen this show, Done this show and of course saw the film. The great thing about a piece such as "Cabaret" is that it is like a lump of shimmering clay in a director's hands. I never felt sorry for the "Emcee" even when I played the part or saw it done in the last mounting at 54, I saw him as a victim of an evil that he helped create. I always played him sort of a sociopath, Having no concearn nor true desire for anyone or anything that wasn't pleasing him at that moment, That is the FUN of this - You can slant it, use a little leverage and give it all sorts of new twists with each production.
The main thing is you must forget Liza and Joel Grey and look at the characters more as archetypes, that is when the most inspiration comes in.
I saw it a few times on Broadway and each was so very different, I enjoyed Raul in the show very much, He was powerful and commanded the stage. I also enjoyed John Stamos and felt the heart he put into it, His Emcee seeming the exhausted victim by the time he sang "I don't care much". And NPH was full of life & great energy and was very good in the role as well. Equal but all very different so hard to say who the "Best" is or was, It's like Chocolate & Vanilla.
I did enjoy Jane Leeves (Hope I got her spelling right) as Sally since she IS British and was very sultry in the role. She wasn't a "Cute-sy" Sally, Which ruins the show right up front for me. (i.e. Jane Harrocks).
The 54 production worked so well since it took you right into the Kit Kat Club and you really could feel that. The weird thing is when 54 starts to rock from the subway and you can feel that - It just fit in with the shows feel & such.
So there is a beauty in this piece that is no 2 productions are very much alike and it is more of an experience. The other factor is being alive in this country today, I don't have to tell any of you that this is the Art/Life dance, I mean, Who knows if Iraq is only a modern day "Boot Camp" set up by twisted evils so that when only the deadliest blood thirsty army will ever be the one that is coming home, and fully "under the spell" so as to aim their guns on their own,... It could happen!
Make of this what you will - for that is the greatest pleasure of "Cabaret", It's YOUR Dream, You may dream this one any way you like, and 99&44% it will still work. Long Live "Cabaret"
Oh yes, For you younger posters, You MUST understand the economy & circumstances behind this show so look to your history books, and on the subject of "Hitler" you must remember, This was a man of great style, Otherwise we would not have a lot of elderly folks in Germany today saying "I cannot imagine what came over me!" The worst ones always come in a pretty sheeps clothing, That's how they get in,.. well, either that or fixing the votes in a National Election, That seems to be the new way.
Not to worry, keep singing and dancing, It couldn't ever happen here... Right?...
"It is bad enough that people are dying of AIDS, but no one should die of ignorance." -
Elizabeth Taylor