Congratulations to Pal Joey — Page 2

LOL. He is just like that! when he has an opinion about something-I mean STRONG OPINION- he holds dearly to it!

I can assure you.. he is not like that in person...sometimes when you are posting, it may come across differently!

J*

I don't need testimonials from friends vouching for the goodness of a poster, I just prefer "opinions" and "reviews" to remain constructive and respectful. I knew he hated PalJoey weeks ago, he didnt need to spout off yet again in a congratulatory thread to the cast about their extension.

He does not know me and should not make inferences about my state of mind when I see a show. THOSE ARE NEITHER OPINIONS NOR REVIEWS and are highly disrespectful.

Thank you Blaxx and Reg.

---

Updated On: 1/7/09 at 02:06 PM

I love WithoutaTrace when he's sweet and I even love him when he's bitchy. (And twitchy. And alive.)

But I never "slammed" him for his opinion. Go back and check the thread.

All I said was, "Now that you mention it..."

---

I don't usually get involved with this. But to be fair Trace did start the slamming..

paljoey, i'm truly embarassed that you were the one who started this thread...and foster, you liked this production? really??

I do not know anyone personally in this thread, so I am not going to make judgments on if they're a mean or nice person. I'm just sayin..

Updated On: 1/7/09 at 03:10 PM

After this thread, I'm going to have no friends left at all...and thanks, ljay, for pointing out that i started the slamming.

PalJoey (the poster) and I have had an ongoing feud about this production, so if anyone other than he had started this thread, I probably wouldn't have even responded.

...and jaystarr, yes, I remember those Xanadu days. I'm so glad we've moved past that rumble in our friendship and we are now close again. I consider you a true friend and would never want to do anything to jeopardize that. You are awesome.

...and one more thing, if i ever saw Matthew Risch on the subway or on the streets, and if I got the chance to get his attention and speak to him, I would tell him that he did a fabulous job as the lead role of Joey and I would also congratulate him on his two-week extension. See, I'm not that heartless!

Updated On: 1/7/09 at 03:16 PM

Gene Kelly = brilliance

Thank you, JordanGirl, for your rational thinking regarding my posts. I am a very nice guy, and was in no way trying to "slam" any individual poster. In a perfect world, I would be friends with everyone on this board (yes, even you Foster), and I am offended that just by posting my opinion on a show I didn't care for, riled up so many people.

JordanGirl, even you and I have disagreed on some shows (Shrek) and we've worked through that and are still friends...and we'll always both love N2N! Thank you for your kind words.

Updated On: 1/7/09 at 04:23 PM

You're welcome WaT! :) Yes, we have had our differences on occasion. But we did discuss it rationally and all is well. And yes, we'll always have N2N!!!! :)

---

Well I'll be sure not to ever get Pal Joey drunk then...he knows more about me than most.

Amaretto, Southern Comfort AND sloe gin...?

And yet...it's so...SWEET.

(As Auntie Mame might say.)

---

PalJoey, always grateful when you put a link to my Pal Joey posting on youknowwhattube (yeah, that's me by another name).

I better not get involed in this mixup as I've made my opinion clear.

Can't we all just get along?

---

Now can you send this brilliant production, which i saw even before the cast chanage, to London...please!

I think there was one of the London production from 1954 but its very rare if it was made at all.
Edit- it was released on very limited LP and mostly just sold at the theatre during the shows run. That makes it extremely rare!

Updated On: 1/8/09 at 10:15 AM