I was there last night as well. I thought it was quite lovely. There were a number of absolutely breath-taking moments.
I'll agree with the set being beautiful (and Lensters quantifying of it's symbolism) but didn't like how the actors were aware of that "water". It seems like it should only have been for the audience to be aware of.
I did NOT care for Hoggett's "movement". It took me right out of the moment. I just didn't get it, at all. (Do you have a take on in, lenster?)
Performances: Jones was wonderful. Maybe it is my own age and motherhood, but this is the first time I "liked" Amanda, maybe I just understand her better. Althought I felt Quinto struggled with keeping his accent consistent, I thought he choices were interesting and valid, and really felt his struggle. Keenan-Bolger was my least favorite, but I wouldn't call her a weak link. I just wanted her to give me more: more feeliings, more layers, just "more".
I found Brian J Smith (Gentleman Caller) to be a revelation. He brought so much spirit, thought and essence to the character. You could see the high school BMOC still shining through.
Please feel free to ask specific questions.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it?
These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.