Good to read you had an enjoyable trip back to NYC, BroadwayBaby.
The story of Avenue Q winning The Tony for Best Musical over Wicked is a famous one which caused The League of Broadway Producers to limit gifts to Tony voters. As you know, The Tony Awards are presented by The League of Broadway Producers to, well, it's own members. They are a marketing tool about making money for, well, its' own members. It is much better to call it an "Award Show" rather than "A Commercial for New Broadway Shows Presented by the Owners of The Shows".
In the case of Avenue Q and Wicked- The Producers of Avenue Q held a luncheon and invited all of the out of town voters who own theatesr or are presenters on the road. He explained to them that Wicked was a big hit and would sell out their theater whether it won the coveted Best Musical Award or not- BUT- if they would all vote for his show for Best Musical, Avenue Q, they would be able to sell out their theater out a second time since many theater goers and theater party organizers will always go and see whichever show won Best Musical. It made sense since there would be a very small audience for the small show Avenue Q on the road if it did not win Bet Musical, so they voted for it.
Unfortunately, when it came time for a tour the producer did double cross the people who made him a success and signed an exclusive deal in Las Vegas, thus infuriating the very people who made the show Best Musical and were waiting for their return on it. The Vegas production was a huge bust since Avenue Q certainly could not compete with the Cirque Shows on the strip and, eventually, Avenue Q toured.
The production you saw in NYC last week has an orchestra of three and Equity Actors on an Off-Broadway contract whom are being paid about the same as people waiting on tables across the street. The Broadway production of Avenue Q was much higher quality with a larger orchestra and Broadway Production Contracts.
Updated On: 11/14/15 at 01:58 PM