Okay well that was pretty perfect.
Yes, except for the Kabuki or Bunraku Lamb puppeteer and the stuffed Chowsie and the bitchy way he directed June in the Mama Was Married scene and song. But that's Arthur--he makes his women bitchy and nasty, just like he is.
But Patti was perfect and Laura Benanti and Boyd Gaines stood up to her. Patti was even better than she was in Ravinia.
Her Some People was stronger, her Small World was sweeter, her Everything's Coming Up Roses more horrifying, her Together more fun and her Rose's Turn more galvanic. She wasn't acting Rose. She WAS Rose. And she will own that role for as long as any of us today are still alive.
I'm glad he cut the rape scene--rape is not as funny as it once must have been in 1959--and I didn't miss the Small World reprise at all. It's a vestige of a second-act ballad that Sondheim and Styne wrote for Merman and cut before rehearsals. Everyone agreed the moment didn't need to stop for a number, but they wanted to give Merman a musical coda to her relationship with Herbie, so they put in that unnecessary reprise. It's better with it gone.
I don't feel the same about the "Hold your hats" cut in Rose's Turn. Sure, it streamlines the number, but I prefer my Rose's Turn uncut.
All in all, as close to a perfect musical as any of us will experience in our lifetimes.
Updated On: 7/12/07 at 11:56 PM