adotburr said: "Lunalaaaaaaaa said: "adotburr said: "Luna when you go toSchmackary's make sure you get the Oatmeal Scotchie - oatmeal cookie with butterscotch chips. So good! According to the website they have it this month! My other favorite is The Birthday Party. Rainbow sprinkles, crushed oreos, and chocolate. Can't go wrong!!!
What I need is an authentic Italian bakery somewhere in Times Square area! Anyone have suggestions!
(we're officially off topic now lol)
"
I am definitely doing this. I was going to take a box of six of them back home, and now I need four more to add in there. (I was looking at the website earlier but it's so hard to choose) The Birthday Party cookie sounds amazing what?!! The website says they won't have the Oatmeal Scotchie on the day I'm going
(Saturday) I hope there's the possibility it'll be there in person! (I'll definitely share a picture of theSchmackary box though)
THIS I wish I had. I'd love an authentic Italian bakery too. I actually heard Sullivans is pretty good!
Schmackary's is awesome because we literally could have them deliver cookies to the Hadestown company, so there lol"
I dont think they'll have The Birthday Party in store now that I look at the website again
Hopefully they'll have extras of the Oatmeal Scotchie!
I go to Carlos Bakery. Total tourist trap but I loooooove their lobster tails. And its on the way to the train haha. My mom's side is from Naples, Italy and they go theThe Feast of San Gennaro every year. I haven't gone yet but I have my bus ticket already for next September. I feel like that area is so far away from the Theatre District. It would be difficult to stop at a bakery before or after a show and able to get the train or bus home."
They'd have Oatmeal Scotchie on Friday though so I think they're bound to have a few extras. I'll definitely report back on this lol Their Monster Mash cookie sounds a little similar to The Birthday Party and I think it will be available this week!
Carlos Bakery also has great hot chocolate! I always wanted to try their cookies, they are so advertised everywhere. The beautiful thing about that area is that it always feels like a movie, there's so much music (literally every restaurant). I recently went to Little Italy though I missed the San Gennaro Feast sadly, gelato from Allevas and zeppoles from a restaurant I'm forgetting the name of. Still looking for a perfect zeppole though!
As an option, would you be able to take a Lyf/Uber before/after a show then to the train/bus station? (I prefer Lyfs, plus they're pretty quick!)