A husband and wife from Toronto saw The Phantom of the Opera dozens of times each. By now they may be over 100 performances. They met at a Phantom performance, and had a Phantom-themed wedding. I don't remember their names, but the story is probably in a newspaper archive on line.
Where it gets really weird is that when ALW announced Love Never Dies, they went ballistic. The previous US tour was still going (the one that ended in LA, with Tim Martin Gleason as the Phantom), and happened to be in Detroit, which isn't much of a schlep for Toronto residents. They decided to hand out leaflets in front of the theater objecting to the sequel. They may have been the ones who coined the expression "Love Should Die."
I'm very much a crazy phan, as many people on this board know. Now that I am retired from my law job, I'm in the process of launching a site and blog called "All Things Phantom" as well as recording You Tube videos about various Phantom-related topics. I'm unusual for a phan in that I started with seeing the 2004 movie, next saw the Las Vegas 95-minute version, and got around to the original stage musical last. I'm starting to lose track of how many times I've seen the show on stage, but here's what I think is a complete count, more or less in chronological order.
Las Vegas -- twice (both times with Anthony Crivello, once with Sierra Boggess, and once with Tim Martin Gleason as Raoul).
Second Tour -- twice (once in DC with John Cudia and Marni Raab, and once much later, in Baltimore, with Tim Martin Gleason and, I think Trista Mouldovan).
Broadway -- 4 times with Hugh Panaro (one of which was the 25th anniversary)
Broadway -- 1 time with Greg Mills covering for Hugh Panaro.
Broadway -- 1 time with Norm Lewis
Broadway -- 1 time with James Barbour
Current tour -- Philadelphia, with Allan Snyder covering for Cooper Grodin.
I have tickets to see the current tour next week and next month, with Chris Mann.
I guess that puts me at 13 times going on 15 for the ALW musical.
I've also seen the Yeston and Kopit Phantom musical once, and the Vox Lumiere version once.
Audrey Liebross
Audrey, the Phantom Phanatic, who nonetheless would rather be Jean Valjean, who knew how to make lemonade out of lemons.