skies said: "Even JCM box office dipped numbers from Michael C. Hall."
John had the strangest box office of all Hedwigs, since he had the unique ability to sell premium seats even when a huge chunk of the orchestra was still available at a discount and unsold. I saw him once when the last five rows of the side orchestra were empty. The Hed-heads didn't just want to see him, they wanted to be as close as possible, even if that meant $200 rather than $99 a few rows back. But, beyond that, he isn't a name and made less of a dent on the TKTS crowd.
It is interesting how when he was announced, people on here were saying it was smart to book him during the winter months when less people go to shows in general, but the rabid fans would show up to see him, and then after that dip, they could get another name in the role... and now in hindsight, that element has disappeared, and he started the decline.
The show clearly has insight into the rest of Taye's run as far as advanced sales, and if there is no major replacement lined up, why start losing money if they were just going to close in October anyway?