I also saw it tonight and actually really hated it. The first act started well but once the lovers met it became song after song of vamping on the will they/won't they/we know they will theme. Another Life was the highlight of the show, but otherwise I was very bored. I can't account for my complete inability to warm up to the characters, but I just really didn't care what happened to them. Most likely because I'm not all that into romances. But it becomes incredibly tedious to watch them kiss and have sex and declare their love for one another for most of the middle of the show. And then when Francesca's family finally returned I just couldn't care about whether she chose to stay with them or not. To me, the catalyst for the family's big fight seemed incredibly shoehorned in, and I found myself rolling my eyes at "Dontchu sass me, boy."
I can see why people will have loved it - it's in the vein of The Light in the Piazza, which I enjoyed. In both cases I wasn't as blown away by the score as everyone else was, which I suppose speaks to my taste. All in all for me it was just a tremendously boring, irritating show.
I know you.
I know you.
I know you.