JakeB is right. The CATS bashing is to CATS fans what "Wicked" bashing is to "Wicked" fans. Not that I believe my li'l voice will stop either one, but still...
Having said that, CATS holds a very special place with me. It was the one show I had wanted to see since I was a kid, when "Reading Rainbow" did a segment on it. I saw it on tour when I was 14 and on Broadway the next year. I have never experienced something like seeing CATS on Broadway, in the theater where it had been playing 17 years, where the original cast performed. And the theater itself was a work of art. There are pictures of it, but to really get the magic you had to be there.
Seeing CATS made me realize that you never have to totally grow up, a concept I'd been struggling with (hell, I have a hard time with it now, at 20). Being in the theater allowed me to feel like a kid, to let the awe and, yes, the magic overwhelm me. Knowing that I don't have to totally abandon my more childlike qualities has helped me embrace growing up.
...wow. Sorry for the long post, but when I get going...
http://community.livejournal.com/ltd_brands_suck/