I'm a biased participant, clearly, but I've found the negative comments on this show analytical and thoughtful, with every single post offering specifics about where the show's various elements fail. Rather than catty, the comments feel infused with genuine disappointment. The three major players constructing this piece are all highly gifted, with extraordinary track records, theatrical and elsewhere. Personally speaking, I've been intrigued with this show since I read the NY Times review in May, and leaped to change my schedule to use a Wed TDF offer. This was the show I was most excited about this season. And I rooted for it to coalesce throughout the long, meandering first act, holding out hope til the end. But I'm not alone. At the intermission, the men's room line was peopled with head-scratchers, many savvy theatergoers rooting for the show as well. The man who sat next to me (excellent seats, row F mezz) has seen everything, and is an investor in two shows. He loves iconoclastic material and expressed it prior to the show beginning; he left at the intermission.
This piece feels cobbled together, both overthought conceptually (though the concept isn't really clearly tied to a specific take-away theme) and underdeveloped dramatically. I was truly let-down that it didn't improve in the second act. And I must say: if a minor character stops the show in the middle of the second act -- the only showstopper I observed -- the show has craft problems. This is not a case of "The Miller's Son" serving as counterpoint. The biggest hit has been given to a character we barely know, and she steamrolls over the rest. It's thrilling for all the wrong reasons -- it makes us aware that much of the rest of the music doesn't feel theatrically purposed. Our inability to decipher the lyrics -- and we simply cannot 80% of the time -- makes the juke-boxing of the Morissette catalog an oddity, not a sharp idea well executed.
I haven't posted much in recent years, but only weigh in when I have a strong feeling and want to share particulars and engage. I found the discussion in this thread very measured and respectful. But disappointment inspires evaluation of where things go wrong. We're not catty, or mean-spirited, we are sad that an anticipated piece of musical theater doesn't quite work.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 11/7/19 at 07:01 AM