I operate on the assumption that most people in charge of any large operation like a Broadway musical, even one that won a bunch of Tony Awards, are not evil geniuses. Maybe they’re evil. Maybe they’re geniuses. Not both.
There are two options:
1) This is damage control. Darren Criss, who is also a producer, has been called back in to stop the bleeding after the bad publicity due to the casting decision. That was my first reaction, because otherwise, why go through all this grief and put your writers and co-star in a bad spot? Upside: While there are still hard feelings (see Wayman Wong’s post above as an example; there are plenty of others), the musical can recover from this. No one can complain about Criss returning, and the show has bought itself more time - and should do quite well during the holidays even if September and October are light.
2) This was the plan all along, as the show states and multiple people on various sites have said. The producers just didn’t say anything and allowed fans to pay big bucks to see Criss in August before he ‘left.’ Criss, who has sang the praises of his supportive wife, has two young children and wants to be a good father and husband before returning to the musical for another stint. Upside: They make money in what would have been a slower August, survive in September and October, and are set up for a big holiday season. And maybe they get a bigger name to succeed Helen J. Shen when she leaves, perhaps even while Criss is still around.
I am persuaded, mostly because so many people assure me that Criss planned to return after a break, that it’s Option 2. This requires me to believe that the producers, including Criss, are a little bit more dishonest than I thought. It partially explains Andrew Barth Feldman’s odd two-month stint, which wasn’t going to solve their long-term problem (Feldman isn’t a box office draw and he’s still not mentioned on the show website, though they did cut a commercial three weeks ago featuring both actors) while creating a controversy about race that has distracted from Maybe Happy Ending’s feel-good story.
There are still many unanswered questions. Is Maybe Happy Ending a colorblind show now or not? What’s the plan going forward? Regardless of the sentiments of the Asian-American community, of which I am not a part, how much will any of this affect the box office at all? (It probably helped in August because people thought Criss was leaving.) When did everyone know what was going down?
Criss’ return alleviates one problem and brings back the musical’s Tony-winning star for an unknown period of time, but it doesn’t address - or even pretend to address - the many questions that the casting decision, and statements made defending that decision, raised about the casting of Asian-American actors in the lead roles.
Maybe Happy Ending is a lovely musical, one of my favorite new shows in years, a well-crafted evening of entertainment that touches on serious issues of how we cope with isolation, grief and death. It also took risks in bringing in an almost all Asian-American cast when the show could barely open and was on death watch for weeks. This whole casting saga this summer has felt like an unforced error from the start, and if Criss was going to return all along, it seems all the more unnecessary.
Apologies for the excessive length of this…
Updated On: 8/21/25 at 05:10 AM