"^ Ha, I found The Full Monty misleading as well, only it was because I've always associated 'Monty' with 'Python.' Turns out it's not quite Spamalot..."
I totally thought that the show was related to Monty Python too. I was like, "Those guys have a musical now?"
I found out about Rent in the 4th grade so I thought Rent meant renting movies from Blockbuster.
When I first heard about Mamma Mia, I thought it was about Italian people.
The first picture I ever saw of Aida was from My Strongest Suit and there was Sherie in the center so I thought SHE was Aida. Not the same thing, I know but still...it was misleading.
How the heck was I supposed to know Big River was about Huckleberry Finn.
Yes, I thought Brooklyn was about the actual borough.
There's a French musical called Gladiateur. Sounds like a musical version of Gladiator, right. *Buzzer sound*. The full title is actually Spartacus le Gladiateur so it's really about Spartacus. But if you saw the cover art, you'd probably get the two confused cuz that could be Maximus on the cover for all we know.
Jelly's Last Jam...actually thought it had something to do with jelly and jam.
Jersey Boys...just thought it was another run of the mill jukebox musical. Didn't know it was the actual story of the 4 Seasons.
A friend of mine actually thought there was a musical version of Juno. I had to tell him, "Different Juno."
I had no idea Interview with the Vampire and Queen of the Damned were related since I only knew them as movies (movies I had never seen at that point, I might add. I have watched Interview on tv) so when they announced a show called Lestat, I thought it was a play with a very odd title. Then I hear it's a vampire musical and, oh, look at that, turns out Interview with the Vampire and Queen of the Damned ARE related.
Little Shop of Horrors...I actually thought it was about a shop that sold scary stuff.
Urinetown...I thought it was about...oh, who am I kidding?
Whistle Down The Wind...I couldn't even understand the title, how the heck was I supposed to get an idea of what the show was about?
Butters, go buy World of Warcraft, install it on your computer, and join the online sensation before we all murder you.
--Cartman: South Park
ATTENTION FANS: I will be played by James Barbour in the upcoming musical, "BroadwayWorld: The Musical."