#1
Posted: 9/19/10 at 4:26pm
*** SPOILERS BELOW***
My biggest wish is that they use Goldman's original book. Mainly because the revised Roundabout ending is an absolute travesty. There are also many wonderful original lines that were cut for the revised version.
My question is: Will we get the original book as it is the official book licensed by MTI? or will Mrs. Goldman demand the Roundabout version?
Now about the ending. Phyllis' and Ben's final dialogue is somewhat similar in the revised ending, but Phyllis' "Hope doesn't grow on trees" lines should absolutely NOT be cut. That line needs to be there. It is very much needed. And where is Phyllis' "Bet your ass"... ?
Onto Buddy and Sally. The Roundabout exchange between the two characters absolutely sucks. The original dialogue is extremely chilling.... and yes pretty depressing.
Here is their full original exchange:
BUDDY: Sally? Are you all right? Come on, kid. Hey, it's me.
SALLY: I left the dishes in the sink, I left them there, I was in such a hurry and there is no Ben for me , not ever, any place.
BUDDY: There never was, and that's the truth. Come on, I'll take you home.
SALLY: I can't stand up.
BUDDY: I'll help you.
SALLY: I should of died the first time.
BUDDY: Cut that out.
SALLY: I should of been dead all these years.
BUDDY: Don't talk that way. You got a lot to live for: friends, a home, some money. Go on, say it after me, out loud. You say it. Friends....
SALLY: Friends...
BUDDY: Home....
SALLY: Home....
BUDDY: We're gonna go home and get some rest...and then we're gonna make plans for tomorrow.
SALLY: For tomorrow.....oh dear God, it is tomorrow.
Ok yes, it's a huge downer and pretty hopeless. But I think it carries so much power. Especially for Sally's character.
There is no reason why the supporting character should come back on stage during the finale. It really takes away the focus from the two couples who just had a nervous break down. I believe the London version brought the supporting characters out, and it was kept for the Rondabout version. It is just so unnecessary.
It is also highly unnecessary to have the two couples try to make amends with each other before they leave. The whole "We'll write!" Come on, really???
In conclusion, the Roundabout ending is a travesty and should not be used. It takes away the power of the piece and the original ending. The original book really needs to be used for this production. I understand a lot of this has to do with Mrs. Goldman. it's so annoying to see that the original book is the official licensed version, but that woman might demand the revisal. If the Kennedy Center production is so set on replicating the original production, it really needs the original book to do so.
Thank you for reading my random scatterbrained rant.
My biggest wish is that they use Goldman's original book. Mainly because the revised Roundabout ending is an absolute travesty. There are also many wonderful original lines that were cut for the revised version.
My question is: Will we get the original book as it is the official book licensed by MTI? or will Mrs. Goldman demand the Roundabout version?
Now about the ending. Phyllis' and Ben's final dialogue is somewhat similar in the revised ending, but Phyllis' "Hope doesn't grow on trees" lines should absolutely NOT be cut. That line needs to be there. It is very much needed. And where is Phyllis' "Bet your ass"... ?
Onto Buddy and Sally. The Roundabout exchange between the two characters absolutely sucks. The original dialogue is extremely chilling.... and yes pretty depressing.
Here is their full original exchange:
BUDDY: Sally? Are you all right? Come on, kid. Hey, it's me.
SALLY: I left the dishes in the sink, I left them there, I was in such a hurry and there is no Ben for me , not ever, any place.
BUDDY: There never was, and that's the truth. Come on, I'll take you home.
SALLY: I can't stand up.
BUDDY: I'll help you.
SALLY: I should of died the first time.
BUDDY: Cut that out.
SALLY: I should of been dead all these years.
BUDDY: Don't talk that way. You got a lot to live for: friends, a home, some money. Go on, say it after me, out loud. You say it. Friends....
SALLY: Friends...
BUDDY: Home....
SALLY: Home....
BUDDY: We're gonna go home and get some rest...and then we're gonna make plans for tomorrow.
SALLY: For tomorrow.....oh dear God, it is tomorrow.
Ok yes, it's a huge downer and pretty hopeless. But I think it carries so much power. Especially for Sally's character.
There is no reason why the supporting character should come back on stage during the finale. It really takes away the focus from the two couples who just had a nervous break down. I believe the London version brought the supporting characters out, and it was kept for the Rondabout version. It is just so unnecessary.
It is also highly unnecessary to have the two couples try to make amends with each other before they leave. The whole "We'll write!" Come on, really???
In conclusion, the Roundabout ending is a travesty and should not be used. It takes away the power of the piece and the original ending. The original book really needs to be used for this production. I understand a lot of this has to do with Mrs. Goldman. it's so annoying to see that the original book is the official licensed version, but that woman might demand the revisal. If the Kennedy Center production is so set on replicating the original production, it really needs the original book to do so.
Thank you for reading my random scatterbrained rant.
Updated On: 9/19/10 at 04:26 PM