Growl: This is true. Isherwood definitely points out elements in the show that he thinks don't work, and finds some parts banal and schmaltzy. But the overall tone is most definitely a rave.
He's fairly beguiled by the whole enterprise, weak spots and all. And his criticisms are leavened with creamy dollops of warm praise, cheering the casts'
"winning personas, Mr. Bowen’s frisky songs and the generous doses of off-kilter humor" While admitting that he doesn't think the show is as strong as [title of show], he concludes with
"Here’s hoping that the family forged by these talented folk — as well as Mr. Berresse and the musical director Larry Pressgrove, who helped conceive the show — will keep making sport of their misadventures, and keep making light but lively musical theater, for some time to come." "Good news, ardent fans of offbeat musical theater. The lovable gang from “[title of show]” is back with an endearingly goofy new diversion called “Now. Here. This.” "This fab foursome is as adorable as ever in its latest creation, a loose and loopy exercise in musical autobiography.... the cast offers up its blend of good humor and good feeling with an audience-embracing brio that never flags." Those are killer pull-quotes. And that's a money review.
"Hurry up and get into your conga clothes - we've got to do something to save this show!"