ColorTheHours048 said: "I was there last night. I really wish I had enjoyed it more, but I mostly found the subject and repeating of said subject ad nauseam irritating and more than a little condescending. It tries to absolve itself from calling people stupid for engaging with the internet for 2 hours by writing a sweet little song about the hope of truly connecting with people online right at the end, but it felt too late.
I think it's unfair and incorrect to say that the show is calling people stupid for using the internet. The main thesis of the piece is to explore the idea that technology has recently advanced so rapidly that humans have been unable to keep up with it, and because of that we now suffer from an addiction and lack of knowledge of how to use the internet to its best purpose. Yes, it advocates for people getting off of the web, but it comes from a place of "I too am addicted and let's talk about this problem we all have." I think of a lyric near the end of the show that is something like "This ugly thing let's me sing so beautiful" and I think that really captures the core paradox that Dave Malloy is trying to explore.
I saw the show yesterday and absolutely loved it. As someone else on here said, it's the best original musical all year, and one of the most fascinating pieces I've ever seen. I'm a huge fan of Dave's work, and his genius only seems to become more apparent with every piece he writes.
For those on the fence about seeing it, know a few things. The structure is nothing like Dave's other work. If anything it's very similar in structure to A Chorus Line, a now-standard book structure looking at each character one by one with small scenes between each character. Of course his music is crazy and experimental, but on the foundation it's a very straight forward structure.
The music is by no means "a cappella" in the way that a lot of people are thinking. Please don't disregard it for that reason. It's not Pitch Perfect or In Transit, it's fully flushed out chamber pieces that are so grand you don't even notice there aren't instruments. Dave wrote a lot of the voicing based off of world styles where voices imitate instruments, so it feels very full and rich. And there even are some "instruments" in it too! Every song is a totally different style and it always feels fresh from beginning to end.
Dave's music is hypnotizing and jaw-dropping in this show. His harmonic structures are unheard of and listening to the extremely talented actor/singers perform it is a marvel. Everyone and everything in this production is at the highest caliber, and the messages and ideas that Dave is exploring are crucial to the future of, frankly, mankind in our relation to something as impossibly large and overwhelming as the internet.
With that said, it's not a perfect show by any means. Dave wrote this thing over the past 6 months or so without any previous drafts or ideas, so it's still in an incubator of sorts. Talking to him and the cast, they are and will be making large changes throughout all of previews to shape it into its best form.
I'll be back to see it again once it's locked after previews, and I encourage any and all to take the chance and catch this piece. It's unlike anything out there today and has serious value both to the canon of musical theatre and to cultural discussions today.
Updated On: 5/5/19 at 09:03 PM