This is by the far LOUDEST show I have ever seen on Broadway... It's blaring, bright, bold, blinding, and brash, and I don't mean any of those things as compliments. Jesse Green opened his Bad Cinderella review saying you needed ear plugs, eye plugs, and soul plugs for the show, but Bad Cinderella is tame compared to Once Upon A One More Time. It's an outright assault on all the senses.
The sound is cranked up all the way. The orchestra blares through the speakers at ear splitting levels and often drowns out the singing. It's a good thing we already know most of these lyrics since 90% of them are unintelligible and garbled. Bright lights are constantly shown directly into the audience's eyes.
The physical production has been beefed up since DC and while it has some pretty moments, it mainly looks pretty damn cheap for a Broadway show. The choreography is the best part of the show. It's high energy, intricate, complex, and very well executed by the cast. There's A LOT of long book scenes between songs, and act 2 plods along at a pretty slow pace and gets bogged down with the "rewrite your story" theme that gets beaten to death.
All in all, this is one of the brashest shows I’ve seen on Broadway. I can’t stress enough just how freaking **loud** this show is (both audibly AND visually). If you’re sensitive to loud music or bright lights, definitely steer clear of this one. I can easily see this show finding an audience of younger theatregoers, but whether or not that audience will be large enough to sustain a healthy run after the inevitable critical drubbing this show has coming its way remains to be seen.
"There’s nothing quite like the power and the passion of Broadway music. "