Official Way Too Early 2018 Tony Predictions Thread — Page 15

I so wish the Park Ave Armory was considered "Broadway"....Billie Piper is doing the best work of the year there right now.

As far as Mean Girls, I enjoyed Ashley Park FAR more than Kate Rockwell.

After tonight, my Carousel predictions are:

Best Revival of a Musical

Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Musical-Josh Henry

Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Musical-Lindsay Mendez

Best Scenic Design in a Musical

Best Choreography

GeorgeandDot said: "Um. Carousel is not winning that many Tonys. Certainly not scenic or revival.

I do think that it should be heavily considered for best orchestrations. Tunick has done some incredible work there."

Did I say that they were going to win? Those are simply what I think it will be nominated for. They have a chance to win 1 maybe 2.

Ahmy said: "Have any predictions been made about Best Book of a Musical yet?"

A lock for The Band's Visit.

What a strange year this is! Best Actress in a Play is really perplexing me as of now. Outside of Jackson, Rash?d, and Ridloff who do you go for. I was trying to discern who is most likely out of Schumer, Thurman, and McGovern (and the women of Marvin’s Room). I put Schumer and McGovern now but I felt weird putting Schumer especially since I don’t see Benanti getting in now!

Best Musical
The Band’s Visit*
Frozen
Mean Girls
SpongeBob SquarePants

Best Play
The Children
Farinellli and the King
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child*
Junk

Best Revival of a Musical
Carousel
My Fair Lady
Once on this Island*

Best Revival of a Play
Angels in America*
Iceman Cometh
Three Tall Women
Travesties


Best Director of a Musical
Michael Arden Once on this Island
David Cromer The Band’s Visit*
Casey Nicholaw Mean Girls
Tina Landau SpongeBob SquarePants
Bartlett Sher My Fair Lady

Best Director of a Play
Marianne Elliot Angels in America*
Joe Mantello Three Tall Women
Patrick Marber Travesties
John Tiffany Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
George C. Wolfe Iceman Cometh

Best Book of a Musical
Tina Fey Mean Girls
Kyle Jarrow Spongebob Squarepants
Jennifer Lee Frozen
Itamar Moses The Band’s Visit*

Best Original Score
Bareillies, Lauper, Legend and Co. Spongebob SquarePants
Bobby & Kristen Anderson-Lopez Frozen
Nell Benjamin & Jeff Richmond Mean Girls
David Yazbeck The Band’s Visit*

Best Actor in a Musical
Harry Hadden-Paton My Fair Lady*
Joshua Henry Carousel
Tony Shalhoub The Band’s Visit
Ethan Slater SpongeBob SquarePants

Best Actor in a Play
Andrew Garfield Angels in America*
Tom Hollander Travesties
Jamie Parker Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Mark Rylance Farinelli and the King
Denzel Washington The Iceman Cometh

Best Actress in a Musical
Lauren Ambrose My Fair Lady
Hailey Kilgore Once on this Island
Katrina Lenk The Band’s Visit*
Taylor Louderman Mean Girls
Jessie Mueller Carousel

Best Actress in a Play
Glenda Jackson Three Tall Women*
Elizabeth McGovern Time and the Conways
Condola Rashad Saint Joan
Lauren Ridloff Children of a Lesser God
Amy Schumer Meteor Shower

Best Featured Actor in a Musical
Norbert Leo Butz My Fair Lady*
Grey Henson Mean Girls
Gavin Lee Spongebob SquarePants
Alex Newell Once on this Island
Ari’el Stachel The Band’s Visit

Best Featured Actor in a Play
Anthony Boyle Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Brian Tyree Henry Lobby Hero
Nathan Lane Angels in America*
James McArdle Angels in America
Seth Numrich Travesties

Best Featured Actress in A Musical
Kerry Butler Mean Girls
Lindsay Mendez Carousel*
Kenita R. Miller Once on this Island
Lea Salonga Once on this Island
Kate Rockwell Mean Girls

Best Featured Actress in a Play
Susan Brown Angels in America
Noma Dumezweni Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
Denise Gough Angels in America*
Laurie Metcalf Three Tall Women
Alison Pill Three Tall Women

Updated On: 4/15/18 at 12:34 AM

LesWickedly said: "While I agree that The Band's Visit fully deserves it, but I think Mean Girls poses a minor threat. Tina Fey is a name and I would love for it to win solely because of how much I love her. It also was the most hailed part of the show. While I think The Band's Visit is a frontrunner, I wouldn't say it is a lock."

Les, have you seen both shows? The book for The Band's Visit is ten million lightyears away from that of Mean Girls. I'm a big Fey fan, too, don't get me wrong, but if she wins the Tony for this, I'll be flabbergasted.

GeorgeandDot said: "Um. Carousel is not winning that many Tonys. Certainly not scenic or revival.

I do think that it should be heavily considered for best orchestrations. Tunick has done some incredible work there."

I personally think that Jamshied Sharifi has that award in the bag, but I think Carousel has the potential to win up to three Tony's; Leading Actor, Featured Actress, and Choreography. It also could take nothing, but it at least has a chance at winning those three. As for nominations, I'd say those three, plus Revival and Orchestrations, but I think that's it.

GeorgeandDot said: "Also, there's no way that the monstrosity that is the set of Carousel will be nominated for a Tony."

Totally agree. I'd say the only design award it has a shot at getting nominated for is Brian McDevitt's lights. Although personally I think that Tyler Micoleau, Natasha Katz, and Donald Holder have that on lock and the fourth nomination is between Carousel and Once on This Island, with Kevin Adams a possibility for Spongebob.

Can someone on here please set my mind at ease on the following subjects...

Please tell me the 3 Olivier winners from Cursed Child (Jamie Parker, Noma Dumezwani and Anthony Boyle) will not beat the, imho, much more deserving trio from Angels in America (Andrew Garfield, Denise Gough and Nathan Lane or James McArdle)

I very much enjoyed Cursed Child, but Parker simply yells/cries all his "big bits" (that, does not a Tony Winning Actor make), and Noma really doesn't stand out to me at all (again, not to take away from either performance) The only one I want even nominated, absolutely deservingly, is Anthony Boyle, whose Scorpius was my absolute fav part of that whole experience. (Again, I loved the show and know it will take home its fair share of Tonys in design, and I will be 100% ok with that)

Long story short, please assure me, if possible that the Potter fandom will not overtake the Tony voters as it seems to have done two years ago at the Oliviers. Angels was one of the most astounding things I have ever seen in my decade of theatergoing, and I need it be rewarded as such!

I wish I could assure you, but there have been far more "WTF" results at the Tony Awards than I care to contemplate at this moment.

Kilgore will be nominated for a great debut, but I'd say she is not in consideration to win. Ambrose could win, but it is very much in Lenk's favor (thankfully). GeorgeandDot, many have been predicting that only My Fair Lady and Once on This Island will be nominated, so it is very possible and I'd say likely.

GeorgeandDot said: "I agree. Carousel isn't anywhere near being in the league with Once on this Island and My Fair Lady."

I thought this early on, and although reviews for Carousel haven’t exactly been glowing, I think it got enough positive reviews to justify a nomination.