Dollypop said: "I'm skipping this one unless there's an announced absence for Broderick. He puts me to sleep."
LOLOLOL... Today was 1st time ever at B'way show where I started to nod off during 1st act.
I'm sorry. I like Sarah/Matt, but I thought they were miscast. Feel free to disagree. I kept hoping Walt Mathau's ghost would appear to save the first act. His facial expressions & voice intonations made him own the role.
IMO, somehow the wife needed a comedian instead of a beaten-down victim. I kept hoping Sarah would pick up the roast beef plate & toss it. Matt comes across as a whiner (much like Producers) than a hard-cold dirtbag cheater. I've seen Matt in Sylvia, It's Only a Play, Producers and I like him, but he's not convincing as a cheat. Too nerdy.
I wondered if Annaleigh Ashford would've been more convincing as a "wife" more ticked off after setting up their anniversary vacay. Unsure what other actresses would've worked.
Apparently, I'm not alone. As I was leaving after 1st act, theater staff assured me the second half was "much better" and that other patrons were not "happy that it wasn't updated to today's norms."
The last time I left a show after 1st act was at the Front Page b/c the cig smoke drifting into front rows. Went back again with a seat further, back I felt bad today. I tried. I really did.
Thank you Dollypop. I like Matt, but I shuffled out wondering what I or the show did wrong!!!