ROB LAKE MAGIC WITH SPECIAL GUESTS THE MUPPETS Previews — Page 4

Seth Rudetsky just posted that he will be the guest tonight. It seems like everyone they had rescheduled out to be a guest is getting rescheduled and crammed in to the remaining shows. I saw on Instagram that Casey Likes AND Linedy Genao were the guests in the same show.

I’m surprised they wouldn’t also attempt to market/tease these Broadway star cameos like Gutenberg

Jay Armstrong Johnson was the guest today. 

BoringBoredBoard40 said: "Quiet possibly one of the worst things I have seen on Broadway. And to make it worse our special guest was Seth Rudetsky.

Such a missed oppritunity to do a cool magic show centering the muppets"

 

So I'm sure Seth tried his best to make himself the center of attention.

 

BoringBoredBoard40 said: "Quiet possibly one of the worst things I have seen on Broadway. And to make it worse our special guest was Seth Rudetsky.

Wow -- from the online comments, this one could end up giving Suzanne Somers' The Blonde in the Thunderbird a run for its money as the All Time Worst.

 

JSquared2 said: "BoringBoredBoard40 said: "Quiet possibly one of the worst things I have seen on Broadway. And to make it worse our special guest was Seth Rudetsky.

Wow -- from the online comments, this one could end up giving Suzanne Somers'The Blonde in the Thunderbirda run for its money as the All Time Worst.”

Hardly. This magic show is disappointing at best due to the promises it doesn’t deliver on (The Muppets). Again, the magic (if you like magic) is fun to see up close. There’s nothing groundbreaking about it or stuff you’ll tell your grandkids you saw live but it’s hardly a jaw dropping embarrassment like “Thunderbird” and especially that “If I Only Had a Brain” moment, was. That’s the stuff of legends right there and I thank God every day I got to see that live.

 

JSquared2 said: "WldKingdomHM said: "Don’t talk bad about Thunderbird! It was amazing. Her rendition of If I Only Had a Brain was a highlight

You want bad look up Thou Shalt Not"



True -- but only if it we're counting the early previews, where Craig Bierko's character breaks into a morgue looking for the body of his victim, but in the theprocess he fondles another copse and singsabout his necrophilia fantasies!



Tugggggboat

"

 

Yes, it is. It ran even fewer performances than Dana H. / Is This a Room, which opened right when Broadway reopened post-shutdown.

I'm hard pressed to think of a show in recent memory running fewer performances. Glory Days, maybe? 

Updated On: 11/17/25 at 11:05 AM