massofmen said: "Speaking of warchus I am amazed matilda will only last about 4 years. I mean you have an incredibly successful book a resonably successful movie and you will only last 4 years? This show was reviewed as well as hamilton for God sake. How did this show not make it into the annals of musical theater?
Are his shows thay expensive to run? Do they not understand budgets at the RSC? I feel like matilda (even though t recouped) was a flop with all the adulation and massive worldwide press it received as it should have gone for 6 years or so.
"
Perhaps Matilda is not really that good a show, let alone the competition with Wicked as their target audiences pretty much overlap. Personally, I wasn't wowed by Matilda, and, having not read the book, find the supernatural elements which comes late in the show somewhat awkward, like a lazy way to resolve the plot conflict. Wicked, while having its flaws, has a very accessible and enjoyable story that unfolds grippingly. Besides, with timeless songs like Defying Gravity, which is popularized by Glee, and For Good, Wicked is also a pure joy to ear. While Matilda has good numbers like Revolting and the swing song, it suffers from an otherwise not outstanding score and lacking publicity. It''s perhaps a book that many peeps have read, but when it comes to a "traditional Broadway experience" which most families are looking for, Wicked is the more coveted choice.