Saw this tonight and was seated basically next to the creative team, so I was kind of geeking out. I liked it, but I didn't love it. Taylor and Burke are really great in it and both have moments to shine. The play is just bizarre. It really doesn't say anything new or important and the secondary characters are all rather bland. The Haunted House sequence was truly just a bizarre departure from what I thought the show was going to be.
The biggest misstep to me was the direction. There was some clunky blocking. Characters awkwardly skirting around a table. And I think the Haunted House sequence would have been funnier with stronger direction. Same goes for some of the low-budge gags at the end of Act 1. If they're going to go for a very "cheap" look, that's fine. But it sort of fell somewhere in between.
For someone that wrote such incredibles plays as Rabbit Hole and Good People, I'm just surprised the dialogue is so...hokey. Facebook jokes, etc. It just wasn't as fresh and funny as I was expecting. But still, I think it'll be a crowd pleaser for MTC.
Also, side note: I noticed Adam Feldman, reviewer for Time Out, was in the audience. Is it too early for them to review? I mean the creative seemed to still be tinkering with the show? Maybe he was just attending, but I thought I saw him take out a pen? Who knows. Just curious!
Updated On: 10/15/15 at 11:06 PM