Hi, divacb.
First of all, I wasn't aware one had to be drunk to have a good time. My mistake. However, I see nothing wrong with going to the bar across the street from the Clearview, pre-drinking, and then enjoying a slushie during RHPS at midnight.
On to the final part of your post: your production IS the talk of the RHPS community, and I'm afraid the talk (what I've heard) is overwhelmingly negative. Rocky Horror is about an inclusive community where everybody gets to go and enjoy themselves regardless of race, colour, creed or amount of glitter. To try and take people AWAY from a cast that will be performing twenty blocks or so from yours (NYCRHPS performs on Fridays and Saturdays) is mean-spirited.
If you want people to react to your new cast favourably, I suggest refraining from comparing yours to the original/other New York cast, and instead try to be inclusive of them. I'm not a member of that cast, but surely you must know what a closely-knit and protective-of-each-other community Rocky Horror is.
Best of luck to you, and I hope you can find a way to be successful and inclusive and friendly at the same time, in the true spirit of the cult following the movie has garnered.
"Well, obviously Company is about the Kennedy family. Bobby is played by Raul, and JFK is played by Harvey Fierstein."
-vfd88