"Broadway songs on my iPod playlist that my friend lovingly refers to as the 'slit your wrists playlist'"
I need to make one of those myself. My list would include:
"I Don't Care Much"--Cabaret
"Someday You Might Love Me" and "Do You Know What It's Like?"--Zanna Don't
"Still Hurting," "See I'm Smiling," "Nobody Needs To Know" and finale--L5Y
"Send In The Clowns"--ALNM
"There's A Fine, Fine Line"--Avenue Q
"Your Eyes"--RENT
"I Loved You Once In Silence"--Camelot
"My Dogs"--Elegies
"Lift The Wings" and "Caoneidh Cu Cuchulainne"--Riverdance
"Drink With Me" and "Bring Him Home"--Les Mis
Non-Broadway songs would be:
"Comfortable"--John Mayer
"Brick"--Ben Folds Five
"Hallelujah"--Rufus Wainwright
"Kathleen Mavourneen"--traditional Irish song
"Into The West"--Annie Lennox
"When She Loved Me"--Sarah McLachlan (possibly the most devastating song ever written)
http://community.livejournal.com/ltd_brands_suck/