SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews- Page 5
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#100
Posted: 4/22/15 at 11:41pm
"the Times doesn't matter anymore. It has zero power good or bad. "
Idiot.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#101
Posted: 4/22/15 at 11:42pm
"I think I like Ben Brantley a little bit more. Then again, he'll probably give THE VISIT a lukewarm notice. Then I'll find him irritating again.
"
At Williamstown, he was enthusiastic about Chita's performance, and respectful of the entire production, with some reservations towards the material. I am hopeful for tomorrow. The production has made several strong changes since the summer.
Updated On: 4/22/15 at 11:42 PM
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/11/14
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#102
Posted: 4/22/15 at 11:55pm
""the Times doesn't matter anymore. It has zero power good or bad. "
Idiot. "
I mean, it's sort of true. I don't know a single person, aside from industry friends, who read reviews to make their decision on seeing a show anymore. Tourists sure as hell don't. Its 2015 people... if someone wants to see a show, they're gonna see it.
If there ever was a season where this above statement was semi-true, it's this one. Honeymoon = NYT raves. Side Show = NYT raves. They're both now dead. I'm not saying this is the greatest show out there, hell it isn't even my favorite this season... but I firmly believe this will be a fat hit without the approval of Ben Brantley.
Some of y'all are so funny. When he trashes a show you hate, you love him. When he trashes a show you love, you hate him.
We'll see what happens.
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/11/14
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#103
Posted: 4/22/15 at 11:58pm
""Glad to see the critics are looking beyond the show's initial shtick and bringing to light the shows flaws. "
Indeed. You'll be able tell the smart critics with an interest in serious musical theater (be it funny or more "dramatic) from the ones that get swept up in hype and shtick by the end of the night.
"
So basically you're saying every publication aside from the WSJ, Newsday and NYT "not smart."
Huh.... ok.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#104
Posted: 4/22/15 at 11:59pm
So as it turns out the one guy whose reviews everyone anticipates most raved "Honeymoon," but it's already done.
Conversely, he didn't like this one, and yet a plethora of other critics did like it.
So what to make of that?
It does seem to parallel what's on these boards though. One group of posters didn't like it. Another group of contributors did like it.
So will the review of one critic (with some backing from a couple of others) overpower all the rest who raved or gave it positive reviews, and shorten this musical's lifespan? I guess we'll have to wait and see.
I saw it in previews and liked it okay. Was it my favorite? No. I would have liked to get a little more out of it. I walked out smiling, but not thinking I had just seen one of the best shows I've ever experienced.
But I have to admit that it also wasn't that bad, IMO. I mean, if it's not your style, it won't resonate. For others, it will. I found it entertaining enough.
Will it last?
That will obviously depend on the crowds. There will be those who take a pass because their favorite critic didn't like it. Or they'll listen to their friends who didn't like it.
But there will be others who will see it because it did get good reviews from a number of other critics. In addition, people who did like it will pass their positive words on to their friends, and so on.
It will depend on which camp wins out in the end.
Updated On: 4/23/15 at 11:59 PM
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#105
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:05am
That Times review is absolutely savage. I don't think it will hurt much, hasn't it been selling well?
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#106
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:07am
"So as it turns out the one guy whose reviews everyone anticipates most raved "Honeymoon," but it's already done.
Conversely, he didn't like this one, and yet a plethora of other critics did like it.
So what to make of that
Pleathora? Seems like the important critics gave horrible reviews.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#107
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:09am
"That Times review is absolutely savage. I don't think it will hurt much, hasn't it been selling well?"
You could have easily looked this up: let's not be lazy.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#108
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:12am
That Times review is absolutely savage. I don't think it will hurt much, it's been selling well!
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#109
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:15am
It's a hit, but not a mega hit. I think that's what it already was/is.
Ben doesn't help, but it only affects the margins. It will run, it will recoup but it won't do either as fast as it might have.
Think Producers, not BOM. I'd take that if it were my money.
Updated On: 4/23/15 at 12:15 AM
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#110
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:18am
lol you think this show will run 9 years?
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#111
Posted: 4/23/15 at 12:33am
Good point, Hogan.
I've been to NY numerous times having family who lives there and the surrounding area (CT, MA). I've seen a lot of shows on Broadway.
To be honest, I didn't consider this the best musical I saw on this latest trip, or even overall. But I did enjoy it.
I think the ones I enjoyed most this time around were On the Twentieth Century, On the Town, The Visit, and Fun Home. I also liked Neverland, Something Rotten and American in Paris, as well, though. They're all so different it's hard to rank them. But I liked them all to the degree that even the show I'd put on the bottom of my rankings was still good. So overall, I was pleased with my decisions. My vote for best musical though would be either The Visit or Fun Home.
I agree that had Brantley and Winer called it a hit, it would have recouped faster than it might now. But it has received enough positives so far that it will do okay for a while, IMO.
And when you consider some important critics gave nods to two shows that didn't last long and have already closed, I guess we can't always be 100% sure of their opinions anyway. No matter how important they might be.
As for "plethora"...well, yeah.
I'm just going off the reviews that have been posted here on BWW. True, a couple of the "important" ones didn't like it. But the majority of the critics posted, so far, do like it.
Updated On: 4/23/15 at 12:33 AM
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#113
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:00am
thats how long The Producers ran
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#114
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:08am
The Producers ran 6 years. Easily checked but that would be for those who care about facts.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#115
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:18am
whew, the brantley review hurt to read...
Im excited about rotten, and will enjoy it for what it is.
Sure it could have been much been with an out of town tune-up, always a good idea
curious to see the visit review
ps pinto, producers ran exactly six years on broadway, am guessing Rotten will not come anywhere near that length of run. my guess 2+ years if it wins enough tonys....
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#116
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:20am
oh my god wilmington, its a mistake calm down.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#117
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:26am
So you haven't seen it yet, sfguy?
I'm with you. There are enough good reviews for SR, and the storyline is intriguing enough that I would have planned on seeing this too…had I not already seen it prior to its opening.
Saw it in previews a couple of weeks ago, and liked it. I would have seen it anyway though, even with Brantley's review. If a show seems of interest to me, and it gets enough good reviews (even if some are not), I'll take a look at it.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#118
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:35am
Now that we have that squared away, yes I think six years is the most they can hope for. I think it will be >2 but if it were 4 I wouldn't be shocked either.
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/13/04
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#119
Posted: 4/23/15 at 1:43am
Brantley's review stands out as the most overtly negative of the bunch. Frankly I am a big fan of the show and have been for some time. I hope it manages to be the hit it deserves to be, whether or not that means a Tony Award.
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/3/14
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#120
Posted: 4/23/15 at 2:07am
"Golly, I hate Did He Like It. Stagegrade was superior in every way."
I feel the same way. With Did He Like It, we only get like 5 critics and 3 different ratings. I like seeing the spectrum of StageGrade; it was way easier.
Critics have much more power in the spring time with awards season. These mixed to positive notices certainly aren't guaranteeing Something Rotten the Tony.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#121
Posted: 4/23/15 at 2:18am
Even before the reviews, I wasn't sure it was a shoo-in. I liked it, don't get me wrong.
But Fun Home is pretty darned good. And The Visit brings something pretty special and unique to Broadway too.
Something Rotten, though entertaining, has some competition.
As good as the reviews are for Fun Home….pretty much across the board…I think it has separated itself from SR. And now that the reviews, while fairly good for SR, aren't 100% in the positive range, has helped out FH a bit more.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#122
Posted: 4/23/15 at 3:56am
Personally, I found it fun for the first 20-30 minutes after that I just got bored. Good luck to them. Meh.
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#123
Posted: 4/23/15 at 5:23am
Also keep in mind that Brantley really didn't like Wicked at all, and that is still running all over the world.
Broadway Legend Joined: 6/5/09
SOMETHING ROTTEN Reviews#124
Posted: 4/23/15 at 6:36am
Brantley's review provided a few laughs.
He criticizes this as "sophomoric," "puerile," and in "bad taste." Uh, what are The Book of Mormon and Hand to God?
"Yet how restrained and elegant those shows [BOM and The Producers] seem next to “Something Rotten!"
Well, imagine that! I didn't know Brantley prized elegance and restraint so highly! Like the elegance, restraint, and non-puerile "humor" of "****ing frogs" and "maggots in my scrotum," right?
And come to think of it, Brantley's most recently-lauded musical offers us the elegance and restraint of someone singing rapturously about exploring another person's inner thighs and extolling said person's "ass" in Levi's.
So here's to elegance and restraint!
Videos
