BrodyFosse123 said: "
As a diehard fan of Bob Fosse's work (and SWEET CHARITY), words can't express how excited I am to see a new interpretation. I'm always excited when artists reinterpret and adapt work. I also embraced Wayne Cilento's choreographic work in the 2005 Broadway revival. I know all of Bob Fosse's choreography inside out so its so refreshing when someone rethinks things - even though he deliciously peppered Bob Fosse's little nuances. Sadly I wish I could say the same thing about Rob Ashford's horrendous "Turkey Lurkey Time" in the fabulous 2010 Broadway revival of PROMISES, PROMISES. His danced Overture made up for it on many levels as THAT was breathtaking. He should have just bit the bullet and honored Michael Bennett by using his original choreography for "Turkey Lurkey Time". Just for that one number.
"
I really have no good memories of Cilento's Charity. I saw the tour and the Frug and Big Spender worked best--but also felt the most like the original to the point that I wondered why they didn't just use the originals with special credit. I do think Stephen Mears' Frug from a recent London production--at least on YouTube, has some good idea.
Completely agreed re Turkey Lurkey in PP. poor Ashford-- in the past ten years or so, every musical geek knows that number thanks to YouTube, there was no way to compete with that. A friend suggested that the Bennett estate, which is notoriously more anal about these things than the Fosse people, probably wouldn't let them just lease one number, but they did allow it with the Papermill Follies and Who's That Woman (another number where the recent revival should have just used the original).