Chicago Tribune is a rave:
Review: ‘The Sign in Sidney Brustein’s Window’: The Goodman play shines on Broadway with Rachel Brosnahan
https://www.chicagotribune.com/entertainment/theater/broadway/ct-ent-broadway-sign-sidney-brusteins-window-review-goodman-theatre-20230505-v3om4vydd5dohfsekril3ozira-story.html
"“Sign” is an extraordinary piece of writing: wise, vulnerable, rooted, funny and, above all, gorgeously poetic in its lyrical aspirations. Sure, Act 2 might have been even tighter if Hansberry had not been dying during previews. But so what? The script already was a masterpiece.
I fell hard for this show when I first saw Kauffman’s production in 2016 at the Goodman Theatre in Chicago, and it’s even better on Broadway where it now pulses with present-tense, in-the-moment acting. I’d swear no two performances of this show are even close to the same; this cast is far too alive for that.
Nobody is sitting in a chair or behind a desk here, nor keeping everyone at a stylish, monologic remove. Brosnahan, an actress of formidable capability, is wrestling near to the death with every other actor in this ring, baring her soul. Her lack of a Tony Award nomination is simply absurd, given that this is far and away the performance in a play all season."