Taylor Hicks to Join GREASE Cast — Page 4

"Any no-talent will work.."

Why don't you go compete with 100,000 other people and win. Then we'll talk about talent.

---

Well, when the Tony noms came out, people were wondering if a win by Xanadu would be the downfall of Broadway. I think Taylor Hicks on Broadway is much worse.

---

I'm the furthest thing from a Taylor Hicks fan, and I have no intention of going to see this show with or without him in it, but I'm not sure why this is so awful. It's a lame production of Grease, not Shakespeare or Pinter.

I guess I really shouldn't care. It's the perfect show for him to be in IMO. I can't stand him, and I have no intention of seeing Grease. It just gives me another reason to stay away from the Brooks Atkinson.

I just hope that if he does do well (and bigger surprises have happened) the people here who bashed him without ever seeing him perform on Broadway will own up to their mistakes and apologize to the rest of us.

If you'll remember, I have publicly apologized for several comments I made on here.

I really blew it about Xanadu.

Sorry again.

(See? That didn't hurt at all.)

---

For the people who don't like Taylor Hicks, what does it matter to you if he gets cast in Grease? Obviously the people "high-up" in Broadway approved him, so who are you to argue? And, obviously he has a lot of fans (The Soul Patrol), because he did win American Idol, and it does mean something. It means that a lot more people will be attracted to Grease, and to Broadway, because Taylor is a familiar face. And, to me at least, that is not a bad thing. And, as someone said, he doesnt even have a big part, so why not let him try out the Broadway stage?

I love Broadway, and I'd like to share it with as many groups of people and fan-bases as I can!

And, I just wanted to correct a comment someone made about Fantasia Barrino, that she is "mildly successful as a recording artist." Well, she's been nominated for, I think, 6 Grammy Awards (the music industrys top honor). She's doing better in the R&B genre then you might think.

My heavens. He pops out of an ice cream cone and sings one song in a show that nobody on here really wants to see anyway. I'll save my indignation for when David Archuleta replaces Daniel Radcliffe in "Equus."

"I'll save my indignation for when David Archuleta replaces Daniel Radcliffe in "Equus.""

Have you heard something? Do you know when he starts? Will he sign? Where is the stage door?

It offends me not because Taylor Hicks will suck...he may, he may not, I don't know and, as many people have noticed the part ain't Hamlet....hell, it ain't even Ursula in BYE BYE BIRDIE and the two main performers aren't exactly Barbara Cook and Hugh Jackman so the point is moot blah blah blah.

What offends me is this influx of people taking over Broadway roles who really haven't made theater--or acting even--they're central passion. You don't have to agree, obviously many don't, but I just feel its absurd that someone should get precedence in casting simply because they subjected themselves to a reality show. There are many superior performers who not only have made acting/the theatre central to their lives who don't want to take part in such a humiliating, public ordeal but have also busted their asses pursuing their careers by less get-noticed-quick means. I feel there is value in paying your theatre dues. Also, I feel producers have become so American Idol happy (and the $$ these people bring in) that they are teaching audiences to expect the expected when it comes to what to expect from a Broadway show.

I just don't think Broadway should be a training ground for reality-show winners to test their acting chops and get more exposure. It cheapens things, IMO.

---

Who is "they"?

"Who is "they"?"

See allofmylife's post. The people here who bashed Clay, and now are bashing Taylor, without ever seeing them perform on Broadway.

---

I don't think he'll be bad at all. But every time I think of him I can't help but think of those car commercials that were played rather incessantly when he won.

If it keeps our NY actors employed, by all means, bring him in.

---

Oh my gosh, GET OVER IT.

He has talent and will play the part fine and maybe sell a few tickets.

It's not like he is playing Iago in a Peter Brook's production of Othello.

He is playing a small part in a commercial show for a commercial audience on Broadway. And the people who see the show will probably love the fact that they can tell their friends that they say an AI winner on Broadway. And Broadway, like it or not, is as commercial as theatre gets.

And, I mean, this show was cast using reality TV. So is it really that big a deal when they cast a winner from the most popular reality show on television?

---