Pashacar said: "JDonaghy4 said: "Its funny that the Woke Police havent complained about the casting of white and now Cuban women to play an explicitly Israeli Jewish role. This is the sort of thing that doesnt bother me at all- Lenk was brilliant, Dacal promises to be as well- but feels like this wouldn't fly in various other shows."
What many people find issue with is when actors from overrepresented groups take roles playing characters from marginalized or underrepresentedgroups they don't belong to. (For example a straight actor playing a gay character, or a white actor playing an Asianone.) With Jews aswell-represented in mainstream theater as they are, and Latinx people less so,I don't think this issue is at play here."
Religion is irrelevant. Tony Shalhoub played Tewfiq, not Jewish. Sasson Gabbay plays him now, Jewish.
Dina is a Middle Eastern woman. By the standards you espouse, its interesting that you have no issue with her ethnicity being irrelevant to the casting process. Incidentally, MANY of the original cast members of Middle Eastern descent talked about how incredible it was to finally be represented on Broadway, and how hard it is for them to get cast in non-terrorist, non-caricature roles.
Again, this is all sorta silly to me. Diversity is important, and I want more and more shows highlighting different stories and characters. I just find it ironic that this lead role of Middle Eastern woman-played with a thick Israeli accent indicating her nativity to that land- has completely missed this discussion.