"The Great Comet" Broadway Cast Recording — Page 2

themysteriousgrowl, I agree that certain parts of this score can sit in Benton's break, but it certainly does not interfere with her acting, or at least it didn't when I saw the show.  I thought she was sublime and was actually brought to tears by her performance in the final scene.  Also, I definitely disagree about Ashford.  The score sat perfectly in her voice and she acted it fantastically.

I absolutely love this album!  It's warm, energetic, and sounds basically just like the show.  The mixing is wonderful and the performances from both the cast and orchestra are brilliant.  I hope Malloy wins score.  This is an absolute masterpiece.  It may be my favorite cast album of the year!

Updated On: 5/17/17 at 08:26 PM

A magnificent recording of an extraordinary production of a remarkable show. I'm in heaven.

The real question is - can anyone tell if they actually used the background vocals they recorded of us in the hall? It honestly doesn't sound like it, but I don't mind, as the experience itself was WAY more worth it than being on the recording for a few seconds. Would love to know anyone else's thoughts on this?

I'm a big Comet fan but I feel mixed about the new album. While I felt some songs have improved  ("Pierre and Natasha", "Sonya Alone", "The Duel) I think the album  lacks some of the intensity in the OCR - particularly in the Bolkonsky songs, "Letters", and "The Ball."  Also not a fan of Malloy changing  one of my favorite line in "Pierre and Anatole"!

"Amuse yourself with women like my wife / WELL THEN you're within your rights" - OBC 2017

 "Amuse yourself with women like my wife / WITH THEM you're within your rights"- OCR 2013

I know its minor but I'm so used to the original line. Oh well. Overall still glad they recorded and released the album though. 

Was it absolutely necessary to record another version of Dust and Ashes? The original recording of this song was perfect, the new recording is not as good in my opinion. I was actually under the presumption they weren't going to record this song a second time and just put the original on the cast recording. 

Theatricality said: "Was it absolutely necessary to record another version of Dust and Ashes? The original recording of this song was perfect, the new recording is not as good in my opinion. I was actually under the presumption they weren't going to record this song a second time and just put the original on the cast recording. 

 

"

Groban sings the original version as Groban, not as Pierre. It makes perfect sense that they'd want to record an in-character version for the cast album.

Yes, it's the entire show. The only thing that might be missing is some of the dance music in Balaga/The Abduction, but otherwise it's all there. The only spoken/dialogue moment in the show is Pierre's line to Natasha right at the end. 

wonderfulwizard, yeah I think even all of the dance music is included as well.

They changed it to the correct pronunciation.

The part after the kiss ("I. Will. Love. You. Anatole." might be my favorite thing from anything this year.*

*I'm still doing my best to avoid all things DEH, until I get the chance to see it.

Anybody with Google Play able to download the album yet?

*EDIT* Downloaded and listening now!

Updated On: 5/19/17 at 12:32 AM

I hate to be negative but I saw the show last week and thought it was ok. The recording is pretty good but my god, Lucas Steele's voice is like nails on a chalkboard.

This is easily the best and most complete cast recording since Hamilton.

Call_me_jorge said: "bwayphreak234 said: "This is easily the best and most complete cast recording since Hamilton."

Both are also sung through musicals."

 

I am fully aware of that...