Tito3 said: "Miles2Go2 said: "Great list so far. Keep in mind that Once on This Island may not still be playing unless it gets a boost from a Tony win for best revival. "
OOTI is already selling tickets through December."
The Great Comet was selling tickets through early 2018 when they screeched to a close at the beginning of September 2017. The fact tickets are being sold isn't necessarily an indicator of the health of a show, sadly.
Adding on to say that I have always found cabs reasonable in NYC so if the hotel is cheaper a bit further uptown, you may still end up saving money. Personally, I prefer being just a little bit away from Times Square, but I've also been to NYC many times. If it's a rare occasion, I'd definitely say to splurge a little and stay closer to the action!
Also echo seeing Hello, Dolly! I don't know who will be in the lead role by the time you visit, but this production really feels like a can't-miss. Like others have said, Once on This Island is also really good and if it's playing it should definitely stay on your list. Come From Away would also be a great pick and it seems likely to be going strong in the fall still, and it's not a show that needs "names" to be enjoyable (though Jenn Colella is a delight!).