plenty in LA... Diane Keaton, Eliza Dushku, Matthew Morrison, Adam Brody, Fred Willard, Eric Stonestreet, Harry Shum Jr, Missi Pyle, the American nanny from The Parent Trap, minor actors from network TV shows, et al.
The oddest was seeing the guy who plays Stanley on The Office in the audience for a student-produced show at my university.
in NY:
Shirley MacLaine at Next to Normal
Morgan Freeman at Book of Mormon (I saw God when I saw the Book of Mormon!)
the aforementioned Jane Lynch (we must have been at the same show, kchenofan)
Brooke Shields at Godspell
Robert DeNiro at Death of a Salesman (during the TriBeCa film festival—that one perplexed me)
I feel like there have been more but I can't think of any off the top of my head
Audra McDonald at Hair, if that counts?
but by far the most terrifying was Anna Wintour at Lonely, I'm Not. She was sitting right behind me and I was petrified for most of the show. I've never been more grateful for a show to be 90 minutes with no intermission! (and I did enjoy the show in spite of my fear)
Updated On: 5/28/12 at 12:34 AM