What kinds of shows do you typically like? What other shows have you seen in the past, besides Dear Evan Hansen recently, or is it your first time in New York? Do you have the chance to see touring productions?
Great Comet is good choice. Cats and Aladdin are maybe not as unique as some of your other options. But if it's your first time and/or you don't have access to tours, I agree with the others: go with your gut instinct and see what you most wanna see!