I'm not sure about renovation, but as for redecoration, definitely the Nederlander. The whole premise of Rent is that it's in the middle of bustling NYC. However, the Nederlander decor is more of lazy, run-down Midwest. I suppose they want it to look authentic NY, but it seriously looks like fake, wanna-be Arizona. The decor is just so in-your-face.
What do you guys think about theatres decorated for a certain show? I think posters outside and signs are ok, but changing the actual decor of the theatre screams out tacky, tacky and more tacky.
Cosette: Roses are red.
Marius: Violets are blue.
Eponine: You're so in love!
Marius: And so not with you.