Mama Rose-Bebe Neuwirth
Herbie-Tom Hewitt
Louise-Sierra Boggess
June-Lauren Ashley Zakrin
Tulsa-Colin Donnell
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/9/04
A few different options for me:
Rose - Tonya Pinkins
Herbie - Don Cheadle
Louise - Nikki Renee Daniels
----------------------
Rose - Christine Ebersole
Herbie - Mark Rylance
Louise - Jill Paice
----------------------
Rose - Barbara Walsh
Herbie - Greg Jbara
Louise - Erin Davie
Featured Actor Joined: 10/2/08
Rose: Alan Cumming
Herbie: Donna Murphy
Louise: Matthew Morrison
I do want to see Donna Murphy in the role one day. Very very badly.
I love Donna Murphy and know she'd probably be incredible, but I honestly have a tough time picturing her in the role.
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/9/04
Screw Ebersole. I'd rather Murphy.
Broadway Star Joined: 12/21/06
I say Brian Bedford as Rose, but only if they try it out at Stratford first.
Id love to see Cher do it as well.
Donna Murphy would be brilliant...
I think Cyndi Lauper could be amazing. Or awful...
Mary Testa, obviously.
She could've been a great Fanny too, now I think of it.
Updated On: 7/18/11 at 05:09 AM
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/12/09
Your mom
She's too old now, but when she was age appropriate, I would have loved to have seen Kathy Bates as Rose.
As for Murphy, I think she'd be a knockout on all the songs, but somehow I don't see her as Rose.
I'm sorry, but the LAST thing we need is another revival of Gypsy. Let the show rest another 15-20 years before it's revived.
I'm with you on that one Hanna.
While I agree that a revival of Gypsy is not warranted in the next few years, that shouldn't take away from the fun of casting ideas. That said, I think Lea DeLaria would be an interesting outside-the-box idea.
I have a feeling that if the movie version does get made there will be no more theatrical versions until well after the movie gets a chance to show it's legs...i for one am hoping the STREISAND Gypsy is filmed...enough with the Broadway versions...give this old "warhorse" a rest...at least until WARHORSE comes out in movie version...lol...which by the way comes into movie houses this Decemeber...
Marin Mazzie.
Leave out the dash....and I'll be raring to go in 35 years! Right now I'm a bit Gypsy'ed out.
Please. It'll be Sutton Foster or no one.
I agree. I think Gypsy can sit for another 15 or so years until Foster is primed to play the role.
Orfeh. Updated On: 7/18/11 at 12:47 PM
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/15/07
"You think I'm going to stand around and let Sutton Foster star in the next annual revival of Gypsy!!?"- Patti/Rose, Forbidden Broadway.
Why can't Sutton do it now? Rose is always played by a woman pushing 60 when the real Rose was 29 around the time when the show starts. Granted, I'm not clamoring for a new revival, but why can't a 36-40 year old tackle it?
Broadway Legend Joined: 3/15/07
Andy Karl, duh.
Sara Ramirez as Rose
Craig Bierko as Herbie
Anna Kendrick as Louise
Why can't Sutton do it now? Rose is always played by a woman pushing 60 when the real Rose was 29 around the time when the show starts. Granted, I'm not clamoring for a new revival, but why can't a 36-40 year old tackle it?
I think it comes down to having an actress with enough presence and gravitas to act as the catalyst for almost the entire show, something that typically comes with age and experience. I find Sutton enjoyable, but I don't think she has that quite yet.
And she has to look like a mother to the adult actresses who play June and Louise.
Videos