Yes, I was there and I didn't enjoy it much.
Most of the roles were miscast, even if they were miscast with very talented people (although I can generally live without Hearn and Patinkin under any circumstances). There was virtually no book in the concert, and for me those songs really don't work that well without the book. (MInority opinion, I know.) And what little book there was was mostly not even the original lines but horrible new stuff that Goldman wrote.
There were a few parts I enjoyed but mostly it was not a fun evening for me, watching material I love being eviscerated. And even the playing of the orchestra was not taken full advantage of. I thought when I went that even if I didn't love the cast, I'd get to hear all that great dance music played really well. I was wrong.
In my experience it was one of the first of those Broadway-related events of which we've now had so many, where the audience reaction is insanely out of proportion to the quality of the performance.
Updated On: 6/30/06 at 02:55 AM