help me remember the musical's name

so, a couple of years ago I stumbled across a song from a musical which I don't remember the name of and I've been trying to find it for at least 3 years (idek if it's a broadway show)

the song consists of a town discussing over whether this guy is a devil or an angel, and like a part of the town is on his side defending him from the other side that claims he's a devil

that's all I remember, I don't even remember two damn words from the lyrics

at this point I've convinced myself I hallucinated the whole thing, but if I didn't, I hope someone can help me out lol

thanks in advance

Updated On: 1/5/21 at 10:05 PM

TheGingerBreadMan said: "“The Devil You Know” from Side Show?"

YESSSS IT'S THIS ONE THANK YOU SO MUCH

I'm happy to have been of service!