legally blonde--yes or no?

People here probably generally hate it, but I think it is a good show. It isn't trying to be anything it is not, it is funny and has catchy songs.

Since it isn't taking itself too seriously, I don't think it's particularly cheesy.

---

it's very entertaining. Like the movie, it's fluff, but you can't deny its charm.

I never saw the show live but I did see the show via MTV and I thought it was fun. Some of the songs are catchy. It's not the greatest show ever written but it's good.

---

Honestly, Legally Blonde isn't the best musical ever, but I still LOVE it. You can't not enjoy it at least a little bit. The songs are so catchy that I work out to them. :) And So Much Better is my current ringtone.

I love it.

---

What parts didn't you like about the broadcast?

---

^ Really? I like it more than the movie. I loved the story improvements, especially involving Elle and Emmett. They have about five minutes of conversation in the movie, and then suddenly at the end they get engaged. It seemed really tacked on.

The score is great, O'Keefe and Benjamin clearly understood the tone of the show and wrote a catchy, tuneful, and appropriate score, given the characters, I still listen to it pretty often. The original Broadway cast was fantastic, especially near the beginning of the run when Laura Bell Bundy's voice was still in pristine condition. IMO, the jokes with the "PMS Girls" were at their funniest with Annaleigh Ashford, Leslie Kritzer, and DeQuina Moore. Honestly, I thought those roles were really nothing until I saw Haven Burton, Asmeret Ghebremichael and Tracy Jai Edwards (who was lovely but surrounded by mediocrity). And then you had Orfeh (who is a STAR no matter what she's in and what she's doing) and Andy Karl, who really tore it up....can't say enough about what a great group of people were onstage when the show opened.

As for faults, there's no shortage. The book is a hot mess. Heather Hack totally butchered Elle's character, especially by making Emmett her fairy godmother. It made believing Elle was actually smart really hard, and unfortunately, people faulted poor Laura Bell Bundy, when in reality, it was the complete hack job done by Heather. The direction was nonexistant (Jerry Mitchell should stick to making up hip-hop dance routines and leave the direction to those who understand it's purpose), and the choreography was passable, but I thought could've been improved. It was also unfortunate how long it took for Orfeh to get a real ending for "Ireland", the one-liner that was in there for awhile ("Make sure you wear four inch heels" or whatever it was) realllllly gave me second-hand embarrassment. Oh, and once Christian Borle started cheating on his wife with Laura Bell Bundy, the quality of his performance suffered, and it was hard to watch the pair of them onstage together. Andy Karl, in my opinion, was a better Emmett than him by a clear mile, but at the same time, you never want to see anyone else as Kyle. Cloning obviously is the answer here, but until that's possible, it would've been nice for Christian Borle to attempt to do something besides alternately snooze and flirt his way through the show.

That was kinda long. And don't even get me started on Bailey Hanks.

---

Updated On: 8/15/09 at 11:36 PM

Wow, Kelly, you really hit the nail on the head there! I Loved it!

I'm so sick of people saying...."It is nothing deep...BUT.." or stuff like that.

Why does a show have to apologize nowadays just for being fun and entertaining??

---

HollyGolightly2: I like the movie better because it's subtle the entire time. I mean, they get engaged two years later, so it all happens offscreen. The musical tries to develop it but still stick to that timeframe, which makes no sense.

Also, I preferred it when Emmett liked Elle because he saw actual potential in her versus just identifying with her because they were both the underdog.

---

I don't think the score is derivative at all. There are a few similarities to Laurence O'Keefe's previous work in Bat Boy, but beyond that, I don't hear "Avenue Q" or "Mamma Mia" (derivative of ABBA? Really?), or "Hairspray" at all.

---