[title of show] returning… — Page 2

Sutton Ross said: "barcelona20 said: "DaveyG said: "Producers are looking for dirt cheap shows to produce and this is certainly one of them.

I find it so depressing."

Depends who is in it."

I mean, All Out and All In was very starry and both failed."

 

Wowza -- congrats on being factually incorrect once again.  Keep up the good work, doll!

https://deadline.com/2025/02/all-in-comedy-about-love-all-out-broadway-1236293428/

https://www.broadwaynews.com/all-in-recoups-on-broadway/

 

 

Updated On: 6/4/26 at 02:25 PM

Grain of salt and all, but Darren Criss is also rumoured to be a part of it. 

Kad said: "I mean, it’s not quite Paris Hilton in Mame but… stacking the cast with big names sort of cuts against what the show is explicitly about.

And the book would definitely need to be updated. It was full of mid-00s cultural references and sensibility. Even the concept of rushing to get a show into a major NY theater festival is (sadly) dated now."

Do the children today NOT know that Mary Stout WAS hit by a hot dog cart???

I've made it no secret on this board that I'm a huge Michele fan, and I think she would be fantastic, but I agree with GirlFromOz68. I don't understand why she would want to do this particular show. I don't really believe this rumor, but she'd be great (assumedly as Heidi)!

The idea of Criss and McHale being her co-stars doesn't necessarily inspire a night of great entertainment in me, however. I really don't like McHale's "schtick" and think that more times than not, he's begging for laughs rather than living in the reality of his characters. His Barfée was painful to watch. Criss, on the other hand, is simply not a strong enough vocalist to be a Broadway performer, period. But he's the sole Tony Award winner in this conversation, so what do I know?

If this has to be an entirely Glee affair, which it does to sell, waiting for Jonathan Groff to be less busy would probably be the more lucrative choice. I'd also be curious to see who they'd get for Susan - would love to see Dianna Agron make her Broadway debut, but I don't know if she'd be interested, and the remaining women to choose from from the Glee cast makes this rumor all the more bleak in my opinion, lol.

The two men in TOS are gay and talk about being gay, right? Darren Criss has publicly claimed he won't play queer roles anymore, which would technically cast doubt on the rumor of his attachment.

As far as Kevin McHale, I enjoyed his Barfee schtick in Spelling Bee, but... he's 100% doing Martin Short in the show (and quite well- somebody get him into Three Amigos the Musical). Martin Short is already marmite to the public, so homages to him will be equally divisive.

FolliesCabaret said: "I've made it no secret on this board that I'm a huge Michele fan, and I think she would be fantastic, but I agree with GirlFromOz68.I don't understand why she would want to do this particular show. I don't really believe this rumor, but she'd be great (assumedly as Heidi)!

The idea of Criss and McHale being her co-stars doesn'tnecessarily inspire a night of great entertainment in me, however. I really don't like McHale's "schtick" and think that more times than not, he's begging for laughs rather than living in the reality of his characters. HisBarfée was painful to watch.Criss, on the other hand, is simply not a strong enough vocalist to be a Broadway performer, period. But he's the sole Tony Award winner in this conversation, so what do I know?

If this has to be an entirely Glee affair, which it does to sell, waiting for Jonathan Groff to be less busy would probably be the more lucrative choice. I'd also be curious to see who they'd get for Susan - would love to see Dianna Agron make her Broadway debut, but I don't know if she'd be interested, and the remaining women to choose from from the Glee cast makes this rumorall the more bleak in my opinion, lol."

Please no to Dianna. A certain group of nutters,  who made awful comments about Cory Monteith when he went to rehab ( including wishing for his death) as his very real relationship with Lea got in the way of their fantasies,  would come and ruin it for everyone else. 

Updated On: 6/5/26 at 05:15 PM

inception said: "The perspiration guy might just throw stuff out there to get his kicks when he sees people talking about his rumors.

I only started following him on insta after someone else there threw a fit over commments he made about the vampire show thing - the thing based on an 80's movie, I'm getting alzheimers the name won't come to me. I think the most shocking thing I've gleaned is that he might actually be a hetero. He's mentioned sucking women's toes a few times. Really? I'm supposed to accept the opinion of a straight man on musical theatre?"

Its a rumor that has been floating around twitter for the past few days.   He didn't even make it up he  just stole it from the internet.

suzcap said: "inception said: "The perspiration guy might just throw stuff out there to get his kicks when he sees people talking about his rumors.

I only started following him on insta after someone else there threw a fit over commments he made about the vampire show thing - the thing based on an 80's movie, I'm getting alzheimers the name won't come to me. I think the most shocking thing I've gleaned is that he might actually be a hetero. He's mentioned sucking women's toes a few times. Really? I'm supposed to accept the opinion of a straight man on musical theatre?"

Its a rumor that has been floating around twitter for the past few days. He didn't even make it up he just stole it from the internet."

That happens a lot and yes a friend showed me the rumour from X days ago , then someone else on tiktok posted about Lea, Darren and Kevin, then someone, in the comments of that posted linked him and asked him if it wss true and he said yes but took several days to post about it so it was not his "tea".

I loooove [tos] and still listen to it and quote it on the regular. But it seems like such a strange show to bring back. I agree with everyone else saying it was a product of its time and its cast. A musical about two guys writing a musical about two guys writing a musical seems like an odd choice for a Glee reunion on Broadway.