I saw the show tonight and I thought it was wonderful! I was completely unfamiliar with the show/music and I was hooked from the very first number. What a gorgeous score and such fine singers to perform it! Elena Shaddow & James Snyder were outstanding! Really really impressive! I was very taken by the book too, I found the story very strong and the final scene very emotional. The only place in which I think it faltered was, sadly, George Hearn. Love him, but he was completely reading off the script the entire show tonight. His eyes were down more than half the time he was onstage. Other than that, I have no complaints! Very glad I decided to go!
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
I'm the first to admit that my memory is starting to fade, but I have a recollection of the big "FOLLIES-in-Concert" at Lincoln Center 'way back when (the one with Lee Remick, Carol Burnett and Barbara Cook). In that show George Hearn pulled out a cheat sheet during one of his numbers. That moment was skillfully edited out of the TV version.
In FANNY, I also felt that Hearn was having difficulty with his pitch and was singing almost sotto voce and letting his mic do the work for him.
I have so many wonderful memories of Hearn in LA CAGE, A DOLL'S LIFE and SWEENEY TODD with LuPone. It was sad to witness him in FANNY.
He wasn't that bad. He's George Hearn. He's old.
But, boy, was Fred Applegate amazing as Panisse. So moving.
And I don't think I've ever seen Elena Shadow before, but she was wonderful as well.
It was actually the best acted Encores in a long time. I was very involved dramatically, whereas at Encores, I'm usually observing a fun museum piece. It helps that the original Pagnol is so strong, and the score is gorgeous, but I liked it so much better than I expected to.
I think this Marc Bruni is a very talented director.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
Now, when will the rumors start about a Broadway transfer?
I'd never seen Elena Shaddow in anything before either, but I know she played Clara in the tour of The Light in the Piazza. I had a very easy time imagining what a wonderful Clara she must've been.
This is one show that really deserves to be recorded.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
I saw Elena in FIDDLER IN THE SOUP.
What a captivating evening, and I agree with PJ - Fred Applegate was so moving as Panisse. A very touching performance in a wonderfully acted and sung production. I'm so glad I got to see it tonight.
givesmevoice, having seen Elena Shaddow in the Piazza tour, I can attest that she was wonderful as Clara.
Saw it tonight and I really enjoyed getting to see this great piece of musical theater! The score has some truly beautiful numbers and the scenes between Panisse and Cesar are just so fun.
I have to disagree with many of you about Elena Shaddow, I was not impressed. Her singing was decent, but to me she seemed a little lost in the role. However, I was blown away by James Snyder's voice... WOW! He got off to such a strong start with "Restless Heart" and his vocal prowess throughout the night never ceased to thrill. Mr. Applegate did give a wonderful performance and its amazing how complete it felt given the little rehearsal time. As for George Hearn, personally I found his two solos to be the most moving parts of the night. Yes his voice is a little shot, and yes he did rely on the book more then others. But, MY GOD, his interpretations of "Welcome Home" and "Love Is a Very Light Thing" were so sincere, the latter almost bringing me to tears. Also, you got to love Encores! for having Shannon Lewis AND Megan Sikora dancing in the chorus...
I saw the show last night, as well, and LOVED it. I wasn't familiar with the score at all prior to the show, but I thought it was absolutely beautiful.
I was so impressed with James Snyder's voice. On my way home, I kept wishing that they could record the show just so I could listen to his "Restless Heart" and "Fanny" again.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
Although the obc has some excellent performances in it, the recording is sloppy and truncated. It would be nice if this cast could head to a recording studio and put a more complete rendition of the score on disc.
Where's bryan?
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
Did anyone notice the resemblance that Priscilla Lopez had to Patti LuPone in this show?
^ A friend of mine had commented on just based on seeing a picture of Priscilla Lopez.
Videos