Hi, I just received a voucher for a free ticket to either Les Mis, A Gentleman's Guide, or Kinky Boots, and I don't know which one to pick! I haven't seen any of them before and before receiving the voucher I wasn't really planning on seeing any of them either, but I don't want to pass up an opportunity to see a great show.
For reference, my favorite shows I've seen so far are If/Then and Next to Normal. Shows that I wasn't as impressed with were Avenue Q and On the Town (not sure how helpful this is.)
Wow, that is great! All three shows are good, but very different (especially Les Mis). Les Mis is more serious and has more depth in its plot, while Gentleman's Guide and Kinky Boots are both light and fun in my opinion. I don't think you can go wrong with any one of them, but based on the shows you have not enjoyed in the past, I would suggest Les Mis for you. I think you would enjoy the story and the music. Have fun no matter which one you choose!
I wouldn't suggest dropping any of the shows you have listed, but if you have time to add a show I would say An American In Paris is also very enjoyable.