They're all pretty pricy. Not to mention it's annoyingly loud in the Theatre District. You can count on paying around $200 a night, unless you catch a sale, or you come at some time other than a holiday.
"I'm gonna jump straight up, kick a hole in the moon. Don't know exactly where I'm going, but I'm know I'm gonna get there soon." - Jerry Lukowski (Patrick Wilson) in "The Full Monty"
Look under features (top left of your screen) and select "hotel finder". It's a bit of a morass, but there's lots of choices and info.
Personally, I've found The Mayfair on w 49th st to be one of the most consistantly inexpensive places in Times Sq, but it's old, small, and no frills. Clean and great location, though...
If you want a hotel that's spitting distance from Times Square and theater but might want to avoid the noise and potential Thanksgiving parade throngs, try places like:
Washington Jefferson Hotel, 51st and 8th Radisson Lexington, 48th and Lexington Hilton, 55th and 6th Ave.
Unfortunately, Thanksgiving is primetime for hotels in NYC and they can jack up their prices. (You're more likely to get a deal in August when nobody wants to come to the city).
You might want to make a reservation, then when your date gets closer, put out some bids on Priceline.com and see if you can get a cheaper price for a hotel. (See biddingfortravel.com for some hints).
Furthermore, hotels in the theater district are usually the most expensive because they are near everything. You might get a cheaper price at a hotel on the East Side away from Times Square.
If anyone ever tells you that you put too much Parmesan cheese on your pasta, stop talking to them. You don't need that kind of negativity in your life.
Stay at a hostel. There's a hotel in Times Square I stayed at over New Years last year that was 100 bucks a night, but I don't remmeber the name of it. Just google cheap hotels NYC.
Thanks for the info guys! I have one more question right now, and I'm sure I'll have more later- How long, walking distance, is 69 w and 38 from times square? Thanks!
If you're going to be traveling by air to get to NY, you should look for an air/hotel package deal on Expedia. If you're traveling with another person or two, you can save a lot. Prices vary depending on the flight and hotel you choose.
"Smart! And into all those exotic mystiques -- The Kama Sutra and Chinese techniques. I hear she knows more than seventy-five. Call me tomorrow if you're still alive!"
Like everyone said, they may jack up prices during Thanksgiving, but during this past mid-November, I got a good deal at the Comfort Inn Midtown (129 West 46th Street). It was right around $200 a night w/an okay breakfast in the morning.