American Idol Top 12

I only saw the first 6 because then I had to switch to America's Next Top Model, lol! Anyway, they were all good, I can't even pick one. I will say this though-poor Camile, she has a great, unique and sensual voice, but no stage persona. It's a shame, because I don't think she can win.

---

So far, I'm going with Jennifer (followed closely by LaToya and Fantasia)

I hate that football player! He makes me want to barf on myself. So does that guy who dances and looks like a grease monkey.

Updated On: 3/17/04 at 11:30 PM

i dont know all their names, but the two i thought were the best were la toya and the hawaiin girl , i thought she was really great, and id love to see her win..whatis her name?!?!?
anyways, this years girls are really talented, none of hte guys really did it for me, exp. in compariosn to last years boys. i look foward to a great competition!!!

---

For heaven's sake, don't try to be cynical. It's perfectly easy to be cynical. ~The Importance of Being Earnest~

I've enjoyed John Stevens from the start. He's not extremely versatile, but I enjoy him as well as George Huff. As far as the female competition goes, Jasmine Trias I think outshines the rest.

---

I thought half of them were great--Fantasia, George, Jennifer, Latoya, Jasmine, Jon Peter--two were OK--Matt and Amy--and two were terrible--Camille and Leah. Diana can sing, but I find her mainly just loud. I think Diana is confused and thinks she is on AMERICAN CHEERLEADER and not AMERICAN IDOL. I hope she doesn't stick around too long. I have to turn down the volume even if she is just talking when she's on.

I loved La Toya and Fantasia. My six year old son likes George. My Husband likes Jasmine. I like Jon Stevens only because his is different. His voice is not versatile at all, though. I hope Leah is gone tonight and Matt next week, then the Pen Salesman!
I love this stupid show:)

---

Fantasia needs to get over herself and fast or the audience might turn on her. She's already starting to bother me. Diana's WAY perky but she's got a strong voice and I like that she takes it straight to the house. George is the only guy that should even be there, the rest are tokens, at best. The Pen Salesman might make it if he were writing his own stuff and had his own vibe but as a more vanilla pop star he just doesn't have the voice or the presence.

Diana and LaToya, George and The Hawaiian girl I liked, the rest could all come or go and I probably wouldn't even notice.

That red-haired girl was a first-rate bore, though. At least she didn't do another Celine Dion impression. The kid doing the lounge act's another snoozer. Randy's right, he's not a good enough singer to pull off that style even.

Leah's at an awkward point where she wants to be sultry but there's still something kid-like in her. She needs another year or two to get comfortable in her skin. She's got talent, she just isn't ready yet.

Hmm, I thought Leah had the least talent. Next to none, in fact. She sounded a little cocky at first when she said 'being a pop star is in her blood' because her mother was one and her father is a musician. Well, it must have skipped a generation. Just my opinion, folks! I thought eveyone else had something going in one way or another.

---

just one question about american idol, way has there been a girl with pink hair in the final all three seasons.

i think the 17 hawiian girl is gonna win!

Wait who had pink hair in season 2?

I am rooting for LaToya and George.

---