No, I'm not talking about the constitutionality of taxation. And I'm not differentiating between state and federal.
I'm saying that taxes, of any kind, are redistribution. If I work at Starbucks and make minimum wage, and pay little to no taxes, I still get to drive on the same shiny roads and bridges that Mr Moneybags enjoys, even though he paid much more towards them than I did. That's redistribution...and necessary if we want those roads and bridges to be the way they are.
If, on the other hand, Mr Moneybags is willing to ride on dirt roads and raft his car across the creek because he thinks he should only pay what the Starbucks clerks pays in taxes, and the country then cant afford decent roads on that little, that's another way to go. But Mr Moneybags doesn't want to have to do that. So he agrees to have some of his wealth redistributed to the benefit of others. Taxation is, unless it's a flat tax, is redistribution at a certain level.
Art has a double face, of expression and illusion.