You will see if you follow our discussion there, why so many of us still think he is good. I can't give it away though.
There are little summaries of every chapter posted, between that and the posts by others it may jog your memory enough not to need to reread. (not that I think you shouldn't.
)
well i am a details whore, so I will reread. I am a fast reader so once I start it won't take too long. And I have only read this one once (compared to the at least 3 reads of the other ones), so I want to make sure I have all the chapers straight. I have been reading along and I love that there are intelligent people!
Oh and happy Fat Tuesday everyone! I really am eating way way too much today, but since I only get two non meat meals tomorrow I think it is ok.
I am also drinkking probably 5-8 cans of pop. Should be fun
The HP thread is not intended to be intimidating, just throw out your thoughts, we don't bite.
On the Snape front I am also of the he's just following orders camp.
I would also like to point out that I've had a Harry Potter avatar for a week now. I'm not jumping on the bandwagon, I'm being fashion forward.
Snape did what he had to do for the greater good.. and if you read what Dumbledore says to him before he dies it can be interpreted as D telling him to do it..
Ah but that's the beauty of the HP books! I really think, as I've said on the HP thread that in HBP JKR was trying to present her readers with all of the evidence for and against Snape so we can decide for ourselves. He tells Narcissa and Bellatrix the reasons why Voldemort trusts him. Dumbledore tells Harry why he trusts Snape. The scene on the tower is very ambiguous. It's up to us to make sense of all of it.
But the question is...can he sing? This is the BWW Idol thread, you know
Well he can clearly act.. Cuz he's fooling someone.. and that's 1/3 of the battle on broadway.. act, sing,dance..
True Yoda.. I need to reread the books anyway. It's been too long.
I think all the HP Book Club people have just been itching to talk about Snape and we haven't gotten far enough to do it yet.
I'd love to see Snape and Dumbledore do a soft shoe together. It would be very sweet
(Exactly right there Yoda
)
Can Snape sing?
Snape sang "All I care about is love" and "The Ballad of Sweeney Todd" in this very competition, did he not?
a la me and my shadow??
I know what you mean Yoda.. It's nice to see an inteligent discussion about the books..
Ooooh, SNAP! Pengers is on a ROLL!
I'd love to see Dean and Seamus sing Ebony and Ivory, myself.
Well you know you could go ahead and read HBP and join in.
/thread pimping
I see an ending production number set in Heaven as Dumbledore welcomes Snape he is joined by Lily, James, Sirius, and all other's who gave their lives in the fight to defeat Voldemort. And curtain.
And he promptly got voted off!!!
Borderline pedophilia creepiness will do that to a person, Cam.
Borderline?
I was trying to be nice. Unlike SOME people I don't dash the hopes and dreams of kids who are just trying their best.
didn't you take him home with you Kitzy?? I know you said both of those qualities were major turns ons for you..
Uh, no. He did ask for my cell number via AIM though. I ignored his request
Oh yes that's right.. I forgot..
Much as I love the whole Harry Potter thing, I need to get back to one of my old avs. I've had 2 people refer to me as "he" in the last 5 minutes.
Oh that's bad.. so find a girl HP av or go back to the box on your head.
I go home in 30 minutes to record on my lunch break. Kitzy with box on head will return shortly.
Use McGonnagal or Hemoine.
Alas, I must go with Sirius or Lupin as they are far and away my favorite characters.
Unless I can find Lily Potter......
Videos