Ok, so I'm basically putting myself out for slaughter by making this post, but I'm gonna do it. Let me say I respect all of your opinions, negative or positive. Also, I admit I am one of her huge fans. But I am not insulting or attacking any of the previous posters, so please don't attack or insult me, I merely wish to state my opinion.
I am very tired of people saying Gaga has copied Madonna. They have done similar things, but Madonna isn't the only artist to do out-there stuff. As for the cover for her single, David Bowie, Ingrid Voulting have done similar clown/makeup covers as well as Madonna. To people like me, Gaga is the Madonna of my time and generation. I respect Madonna, but I don't connect to her and I dislike the comparisons.
As for the sound,
@javero got it right. If you watch interviews she quotes many bands that have the 80's sound as inspirations. Also, Applause is not all about her fame and fortune. She said she dedicated it to her fans who helped her through her surgery etc. It's also about not caring wha critics say, it's whether the fans clap. Just like Broadway, critics may dislike shows, but the performers care about how the audience applauds and cheers them.
Hence that video telling people to not buy her album. It's all a joke. She's crazy I admit, but she's tired of critics and gossip running pop music. And I doubt it will tank. The single is #1 in many countries, and the album is on pre-order. In a time where most people get their music free, that's impressive.
So I'm done, I know I'm a mega fan so my opinion is biased, but I think people need to really know an artist before they make opinions. Like she said on Twitter: Let's make 2013 a year where music/talent/artistry is more important than gossip/fanwars I respect all fanbases 4 their passion
And
Dont focus on ANY blogger criticism. I have been a producer/songwriter/musician for over 10 years. Trust the artist bloggers are not critics. The fans + music scholars are the best critics because they know the artist intimately