Her tour sales were a disaster in South America, they gave half the tickets to a few of the stadium shows away in things like Ice Lollies for free. Russia didn't sell well, France was downsized to a smaller venue, the 2nd Twickenham show that was billed as 'sold out' in the UK was half empty etc etc, her people and herself did a very good job of trying to cover it up, sadly for her people have cell phones and cameras.
When her figures were released for the shows she did in North America before the 'hip injury' were released she averaged 9 thousand tickets sold per venue, sadly most of the venues were 16 to 18 thousand so it showed she was not selling (The first night in the states had many empty seats and each venue seemed to follow the same patten, many tickets were given for free last minute to radio stations, fans at the Born This Way bus etc). I think it's safe to say the hip thing was a load of rubbish (especially seeing her turn up at venues in her wheelchair surrounded by paparazzi but then inside the venue photographed walking in heels)
I am glad the finally the media are getting on to her. We will never know how many albums she actually would have sold with BTW because she sold them for 99 cents, homeless people could afford it. This time around it's the APP that is already proving that her sales figures wont really reflect what she has actually sold, the company knew that after BTW any album she released under just normal formats at normal price would be far far lower than BTW, that's why this App thing is been used.
Namo i love u but we get it already....you don't like Madonna