(Confession: I have now read the thread ... well, most of it anyway ...)
I think the last shot was heavy-handed. Bitterly funny? Perhaps. Completely out of place? Absolutely. The drawing of the rats in the midst of the film is one thing; a rat running across a balcony ledge with the elusive golden dome in the background to end it puts no faith in your audience or your own filmmaking that the film's message was understood. I thought it was a very poor and unneccesary choice.
I am another who thinks that singling out Marky Mark was an odd choice; what made his performance better, stronger or greater than anyone else's? Matt Damon stood out for me, primarily for his charming scenes with the female therapist. They had a lovely chemistry. I thought Jack was Jack. Someone made comment here about Nicholson imitating his own acting (or something like that) ... excellent point.
lildogs, I did not think Matt Damon's character was gay; I thought his impotency could be attributed to his moral wrangling about the mess in which he found himself.
Finally (for now), I think it is difficult to compare films against each other, unless two people make different films using the same script or story. I do think, however, that films can be judged by their own craft and how well they succeed in reaching the goals they achieved or that the audience has set for the film. For example, "The Departed" is a good film, but, for me, it does not break any new ground in the genre (one for which, admittedly, I do not care), something that, based on the praise, I expected it to do, nor was the acting so outstanding as to elevate it beyond its beginnings. "The Queen," on the other hand, sets out to explore the possible inner life and conflict of one person to gain a new understanding of a situation. The script is solid; the acting exquisite; the direction delicate and carefully rendered. Though they are vastly different films, I think "The Queen" is a better film than "The Departed."
(Flame away.)
"I am open, and I am willing,
For to be hopeless would seem so strange.
It dishonors those who go before us,
So lift me up to the light of change."
Holly Near