Personally, I think the whole thing was really not about Susan Boyle's performance as it was about the audience reaction, which is why the clip went viral, sending her into the stratosphere. It's a great clip. I don't know the official screening process of the show, so I won't pretend to know the authenticity of Simon's reaction nor is it actually important in any way, really. At this point, it's entirely moot. I do think she's talented, but it's not the greatest performance of the song. Given the stress of the situation, which appeared to have been heightened by the heckling audience, I thought her nerves came through in her performance, but she held on and pushed through quite admirably. The continued attention lavished on her is entirely media-driven, for which she truly cannot be blamed. But for me, I'd rather endure a lifetime of Susan Boyle than 15 minutes of Paris Hilton. I'm pretty grateful this happened, actually.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian